ADVERTISEMENT

Biden forgives $10,000 of student loan debt for millions of debtors

Ok I get it. I am a Mensa international founder. Me, just acting to be a common man actually meas that I don't want to offend any illiterates from attempting to join Mensa.
There is zero opportunity to claim Pub or Conservative or patriot in one hand, and vote for brandon in the other because of trumps mean tweets. Zero opportunity. You and any like you, are shills. Saddly "your" votes are what we all are paying for. I hope you feel the shame you have brought to the American Flag. It apparent you want the republic to fall. You are getting you wish. Beyond pathetic, because of your "republican" feels got a rash on them. Monkey Pox Aloha.
Not that he needs me defending him, but the crap you and a couple others post to Aloha reflects poorly on you. It also confirms what most real Republicans and true Independents think of Trump cult members like you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bill4411
The shaft argument doesn't mean anything to me. I know several people who had their houses taken for I69 (I live right next to it, my kids went to school with several families impacted). They did not want to leave, but had to. Every time the defense department chooses a weapons system, investors in a different system lose.

Heck, I paid off my PLUS loan when COVID started. I don't feel cheated some people waited and get an advantage. Good for them. It is like I don't care if coworkers get raises, good for them. If you win the lottery, good for you. I don't need to feel jealous.

That said, there are other good reasons to oppose the plan. It does not tackle the real problem, it skips the role of Congress in our system, and it costs money that may be better spent elsewhere (public education would be a better choice). But jealousy someone gets help doesn't work for me.
It’s an income transfer.
 
It’s an income transfer.
Lots of things are. We spent massive amounts on ships the navy did not want, that did not nor still do not work, just so some defense contractors could get rich.

 
Wrong. The party now has factions. Not unlike the Dems
There have always been factions. I know this is Wikipedia but Reagan described the GOP as a three legged stool:


Reagan's three factions were the social conservatives, the fiscal conservatives, and the foreign interventionists (Neo-Cons). I think you see some overlap between the three and it also does not take into account the more Libertarian wing of the party (the MTIOTF and RZ's). Over my lifetime, the fiscal and Neo-Con gardens of the party have been the most watered. When election time came, that third leg of the party would get all sorts of lip service, but they did not get watered. The GOP has been quick to come with a tax cut and a foreign intervention. Grenada, Panama, Iraq 1, Iraq 2, Afghanistan...you get the point on the neo-con front and that isn't taking into account our role as the "world's police" where we were just "riding the beat" as opposed to actually getting out and attempting an "arrest". That third leg has fairly dutifully gone out and voted for the party time and time again even though they were not really having their interests served. The GOP was talk and bluster on the cultural issues but was always quick to retreat from those fights. Trump came along and pissed off the neo-cons (a bunch of the conservative commentator class was in this category), he did take care of the fiscal conservatives first (they always get their tax break) but he cheeses them off with anti-free (free being a misnomer) trade policies. And it elevated the dummies who are supposed to just vote because the other guys are worse.

For the social cons, the other two legs of that stool have been a pretty shitty group of allies. All talk, no play. And when they have the chance to play or something went through that maybe wasn't in their wheel house, they abandoned the party and the vitriol some have had for their "allies" has been as bad or worse than the actual political opposition. And here we are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DANC
Not that he needs me defending him, but the crap you and a couple others post to Aloha reflects poorly on you. It also confirms what most real Republicans and true Independents think of Trump cult members like you.
75 million is a lot of Cult members. MAGA.
 
Lots of things are. We spent massive amounts on ships the navy did not want, that did not nor still do not work, just so some defense contractors could get rich.

How do we reign in wasteful spending?
Student loan forgiveness results in the transfer from low income to higher income. Financed by the percentage that are taxpayers.
I think we have a poster on here that calls them “vote whores”. Both Democratic and Republican. We are all being played.
 
How do we reign in wasteful spending?
Student loan forgiveness results in the transfer from low income to higher income. Financed by the percentage that are taxpayers.
I think we have a poster on here that calls them “vote whores”. Both Democratic and Republican. We are all being played.
You want reign in wasteful spending! Quit giving money to Ukraine.
 
How do we reign in wasteful spending?
Student loan forgiveness results in the transfer from low income to higher income. Financed by the percentage that are taxpayers.
I think we have a poster on here that calls them “vote whores”. Both Democratic and Republican. We are all being played.
Wasteful spending is different from the argument that it isn't fair. I have never disagreed that there are better uses for this money, I listed that as a reason to oppose it.

The post you quoted was referencing, "oh woe is me, I paid off my loan 10 years ago and now someone is getting a $10,000 break, my life isn't worth living" fainting couch attack.

We often talk of a sense of accomplishment for a job well done, someone paying off their debt should have that sense.

Now none of that means this bill does not cost money we could either spend better or not spend, none of the above means this bill attacks the root problems as it does not. None of the above means our government functioned as it should be having congressional approval and it does not.

Wasteful spending needs tackled, in all areas of spending (social programs and military). I have said in the past we need to review all programs and determine how well they are addressing their purpose, and how large of a military we need vs want.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hoosboot
cleared my schedule
8CrR.gif
 
Because the topic was student loans.
Yeah, but I think the REAL topic is about taxpayers paying for forgiven loans, isn't it?

Like MTG's $183k PPP loan that was forgiven.

Like Vern Buchanan's $2.3M PPP loan that was forgiven.

Like Matt Gaetz's $482k PPP loan that was forgiven.

Feel free to list off some Ds that got huge PPP loans forgiven. Equal opportunity criticism here from me. But the hypocrisy of the bozos listed above is too much to not point out for me.
 
Yeah, but I think the REAL topic is about taxpayers paying for forgiven loans, isn't it?

Like MTG's $183k PPP loan that was forgiven.

Like Vern Buchanan's $2.3M PPP loan that was forgiven.

Like Matt Gaetz's $482k PPP loan that was forgiven.

Feel free to list off some Ds that got huge PPP loans forgiven. Equal opportunity criticism here from me. But the hypocrisy of the bozos listed above is too much to not point out for me.
PPP loans is a different topic with different intentions, circumstances and goals.

The loans (and they really weren't loans for most businesses) were designed to support an economy that was on hold. Keep employees paid and businesses afloat so those employees could come back etc. While I am quite sure there was fraud committed by fine individuals on both sides of the aisle...the circumstances made them legitimate.

Student loan handouts are simply paying for votes with taxpayer dollars. A massive slap in the face and kick to the groin to the millions that paid their debts.
 
Yeah, but I think the REAL topic is about taxpayers paying for forgiven loans, isn't it?

Like MTG's $183k PPP loan that was forgiven.

Like Vern Buchanan's $2.3M PPP loan that was forgiven.

Like Matt Gaetz's $482k PPP loan that was forgiven.

Feel free to list off some Ds that got huge PPP loans forgiven. Equal opportunity criticism here from me. But the hypocrisy of the bozos listed above is too much to not point out for me.
How did Gaetz or MTG qualify for such loans? Awful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon_mya1phvcpf5x4
How did Gaetz or MTG qualify for such loans? Awful.
Like all things I suspect we don't have the rest of the story. If it's a business with payroll and it was approved that was the purpose behind it. Or maybe they were shareholders in a biz that used it for payroll. Perfectly fine. That's just the English being the English.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DANC
You have numerous Dems in this thread saying they are against it
I had originally addressed that point, discussing people in the thread but removed it prior to posting. I felt that most of the opposition in the thread was coming from people that were pre disposed to vote GOP in the upcoming elections. I did say that although there were individual Dems in the thread saying they didn't agree, I hadn't seen any of them post that it made them more inclined to vote for the GOP candidate, who basically is opposite of their view on nearly every other issue...

But I left out that whole conversation because I felt it made the post too long. So I decided to concentrate on Dems as a whole, and not discuss this board in particular. I have seen some blow back from more moderate candidates, but in discussions with people I know (who certainly aren't rich) I don't see that they are upset.

I asked one friend this morning about her son, who graduated a few years back and is getting married next month. She said that she wasn't sure if he qualified but she certainly hoped so because he had been working since 14, worked three jobs to put himself thru school and still had to take out loans which are still a huge drain to pay off because of the way the interest compounds and he can never get anything applied to the principal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon_mya1phvcpf5x4
  • Angry
Reactions: anon_mya1phvcpf5x4
PPP fraud under Trump's CARES Act was one of the largest collective swindles in US history.


And the gall of these people to turn around and make a big ordeal about student loan forgiveness when they took a lot more than $10,000
 
I had originally addressed that point, discussing people in the thread but removed it prior to posting. I felt that most of the opposition in the thread was coming from people that were pre disposed to vote GOP in the upcoming elections. I did say that although there were individual Dems in the thread saying they didn't agree, I hadn't seen any of them post that it made them more inclined to vote for the GOP candidate, who basically is opposite of their view on nearly every other issue...

But I left out that whole conversation because I felt it made the post too long. So I decided to concentrate on Dems as a whole, and not discuss this board in particular. I have seen some blow back from more moderate candidates, but in discussions with people I know (who certainly aren't rich) I don't see that they are upset.

I asked one friend this morning about her son, who graduated a few years back and is getting married next month. She said that she wasn't sure if he qualified but she certainly hoped so because he had been working since 14, worked three jobs to put himself thru school and still had to take out loans which are still a huge drain to pay off because of the way the interest compounds and he can never get anything applied to the principal.
And I'm sure their other neighbor who became a bricklayer and didn't go to college is thrilled to subsidize that kid's loan. always looking for someone else to foot the bill. You always miss the point cosmic
 
Last edited:
Yes. Some law schools have plans where they help pay them back like PSLF. And I’m sure some parents or relatives pay them off once they done (they sometimes do).

And law school can be over $100k a year so rich is relative.
You never know how accurate comments from strangers on line are, but a poster replying to one of the stories on yahoo yesterday really stood out to me. Pushing back that most of the students would be lining up $150,000/yr positions...

"I graduated from a top 20 university with a good GPA. I started out making 35K a year and have slowly made it 80k. My mother made 10k a year during my time in college, because my father had just passed. But because he just passed, for the next two years my student aid did not meet the poverty level, even though I was in poverty. Trust me, it isn't just rich kids going to college. In addition I started out only having to borrow 4k a year that I worked off every school year. But then tuition almost tripled in those 4 years and I had to borrow a lot. I essentially went from a full scholarship to borrowing from peter to pay paul just to graduate. You clearly haven't been to college, because you'd know right now my average starting pay from college in my field is still only 55k. I literally graduated from the best accounting school in the World that year. Don't tell me it is rich kids. Those kids didn't borrow a dime unless it was financially strategic for their families to do so."

When I was at IU, my instate tuition was roughly $35/hr, so my semester tuition was like $400. Add another $1500 a year or so for the dorms (which included meals) and my base cost was about $2000/yr. My dad was a veteran, so I basically was able to go at least undergrad on his VA benefits/Social security. I did have to take out loans for grad school, but I really can't relate to the astronomical costs of college today.

I certainly don't begrudge the folks who get this benefit, but it's not an issue I'm particularly invested in one way or another. But it is interesting to see a worthless POS MTG who lives off her husbands wealth and whose family business received a $140,000 or so PPA loan write off to attack people getting far less (on average) than she did...
 
And the gall of these people to turn around and make a big ordeal about student loan forgiveness when they took a lot more than $10,000
I get it now. Libs claim Lucy is a face account and now I realize you're a conservative posting as an idiot to make libs look stupid.

Congratulation! It's working!
 
You never know how accurate comments from strangers on line are, but a poster replying to one of the stories on yahoo yesterday really stood out to me. Pushing back that most of the students would be lining up $150,000/yr positions...

"I graduated from a top 20 university with a good GPA. I started out making 35K a year and have slowly made it 80k. My mother made 10k a year during my time in college, because my father had just passed. But because he just passed, for the next two years my student aid did not meet the poverty level, even though I was in poverty. Trust me, it isn't just rich kids going to college. In addition I started out only having to borrow 4k a year that I worked off every school year. But then tuition almost tripled in those 4 years and I had to borrow a lot. I essentially went from a full scholarship to borrowing from peter to pay paul just to graduate. You clearly haven't been to college, because you'd know right now my average starting pay from college in my field is still only 55k. I literally graduated from the best accounting school in the World that year. Don't tell me it is rich kids. Those kids didn't borrow a dime unless it was financially strategic for their families to do so."

When I was at IU, my instate tuition was roughly $35/hr, so my semester tuition was like $400. Add another $1500 a year or so for the dorms (which included meals) and my base cost was about $2000/yr. My dad was a veteran, so I basically was able to go at least undergrad on his VA benefits/Social security. I did have to take out loans for grad school, but I really can't relate to the astronomical costs of college today.

I certainly don't begrudge the folks who get this benefit, but it's not an issue I'm particularly invested in one way or another. But it is interesting to see a worthless POS MTG who lives off her husbands wealth and whose family business received a $140,000 or so PPA loan write off to attack people getting far less (on average) than she did...
How did you get VA and SS payments? Was your father disabled?

You don't get those benefits just because he was a veteran.
 
And I'm sure their other neighbor who became a bricklayer and didn't go to college is thrilled to subsidy that kid's loan. always looking for someone else to foot the bill
I have no idea, I only know her from the dog park and just met her a month or two ago. I do know that she's recently retired from being a nurse at IU health, that her husband died of ALS prior to their son going to IU, and that she had a daughter a few years older than her son who died suddenly of a pulmonary embolism about 5 yrs ago. I think her son works for the forestry service in Colorado and I know she's driving out there next month for the wedding....
 
How did you get VA and SS payments? Was your father disabled?

You don't get those benefits just because he was a veteran.
Is dead disabled? He died when I was 10, in 1965...He was 41..., and the last of my Grandma's 3 sons and husband to die of heart disease. All 3 of the boys died before age 45...
 
I have no idea, I only know her from the dog park and just met her a month or two ago. I do know that she's recently retired from being a nurse at IU health, that her husband died of ALS prior to their son going to IU, and that she had a daughter a few years older than her son who died suddenly of a pulmonary embolism about 5 yrs ago. I think her son works for the forestry service in Colorado and I know she's driving out there next month for the wedding....
None of which has anything to do with compelling others to pay. Gofundme and taxes aren't the same
 
  • Like
Reactions: DANC
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT