If YOU were forced to decide....

[Dugger-Hoosier]

Was going to make a top 3, but that is CMW decision. Only thing I have to say is that Kopp and Stewart should never be on the court at the same time. Both are average defenders at best and out there to knock down shots. I think they are totally interchangeable, basically the same player. I think they should split minutes between each other if they both come back.

 

[asindc]

I'd lean towards keeping Phin as for a couple of reasons: 1) I don't think we'd get a better PG than Phin in the portal with XJ slotted in the starting spot, 2) I don't want to rely on a freshman combo guard (JHS) as the backup PG - JHS could certainly beat out Phin for that role, I just don't want to count on it. 3) worst case is that Phin a reliable ball handler and solid defender behind XJ and which might allow JHS to play more minutes off the ball if JHS isn't ready to be a PG at the college level.

I agree with all your points. If Phin could get back even just 85-90% of the offensive game he had as a freshman, he could solidity the point with XJ and allow CMW to gradually bring JHS along.