ADVERTISEMENT

IU is no longer an elite basketball school. Change my mind.

It would take five or six years straight of bad results for that to happen. Indiana has one of the most loyal fan bases there is and people show up no matter what. I think you would probably have to miss the tournament for five or six straight years to see a half empty stadium. One of the reasons the admins do not care cause the place is still sold out.
My Dad used to say that it was the fans fault the Cubs weren't very good. He said, "son, they put 2 million people in those seats a year even if they only win 60 games".
 
  • Like
Reactions: IndyAuthor
Most elite basketball programs are simply the product of a single coach:

IU and Knight
Syracuse and Boeheim
UConn and Calhoun
Duke and Coach K
Michigan State and Izzo
Villanova and Wright
UVA and Bennett.

Only a few blue bloods can maintain eliteness across several coaches:

Kansas - Brown, Williams, Self
UNC - Smith, Williams
Kentucky - Rupp, Smith, Calipari
UCLA - Wooden, Harrick

You'll notice that even these blue bloods will struggle from time to time with the wrong coach. Kentucky had Gillespie. UNC had Matt Doherty. UCLA had Lavin and Alford.

This evidence should lead us to believe that coaching is paramount to college bball success. UNC on the jersey means nothing when Matt Doherty is coaching. Indiana on the jersey means nothing when clappy CTC is coaching. Coaching hires, then, are the critical decision points that determine whether a program will be elite or not.

But elite coaches don't grow on trees. IU is now struggling with middling coaches like CTC and CAM. Much like UConn could not find another elite coach, and is now a bottom feeder, so too is IU a bottom feeder, not having found an elite coach.

Therefore, IU basketball is no longer an elite program. Change my mind.
No, we are not an elite basketball school, duh. We can't even make the tournament.
 
Most elite basketball programs are simply the product of a single coach:

IU and Knight
Syracuse and Boeheim
UConn and Calhoun
Duke and Coach K
Michigan State and Izzo
Villanova and Wright
UVA and Bennett.

Only a few blue bloods can maintain eliteness across several coaches:

Kansas - Brown, Williams, Self
UNC - Smith, Williams
Kentucky - Rupp, Smith, Calipari
UCLA - Wooden, Harrick

You'll notice that even these blue bloods will struggle from time to time with the wrong coach. Kentucky had Gillespie. UNC had Matt Doherty. UCLA had Lavin and Alford.

This evidence should lead us to believe that coaching is paramount to college bball success. UNC on the jersey means nothing when Matt Doherty is coaching. Indiana on the jersey means nothing when clappy CTC is coaching. Coaching hires, then, are the critical decision points that determine whether a program will be elite or not.

But elite coaches don't grow on trees. IU is now struggling with middling coaches like CTC and CAM. Much like UConn could not find another elite coach, and is now a bottom feeder, so too is IU a bottom feeder, not having found an elite coach.

Therefore, IU basketball is no longer an elite program. Change my mind.

We haven't been for more than 25 years, like a lot of us have been saying. You finally noticed?
 
Two freshmen in your backcourt breeds inconsistency. Look at the last 2 recruiting classes (Archie's only ones 19+20) and try to convince me other schools who aren't elite get that many 4 and 5 star kids. This team was very young and very beat up. If you couldn't see strides being made once the roster was relatively healthy, you weren't watching. This effects things like practice (not enough bodies to play 5 on 5 and not able to play best against best), fatigue, new injuries, confidence, rhythm, and the simple fact you are doing without players you counted on being there. Do people really forget how much of a rebuild this has been? Its beyond ridiculous to expect a coach to turn around a program before his 2nd recruiting class is even on campus. Why are our fans getting to be so stupid.

Most elite basketball programs are simply the product of a single coach:

IU and Knight
Syracuse and Boeheim
UConn and Calhoun
Duke and Coach K
Michigan State and Izzo
Villanova and Wright
UVA and Bennett.

Only a few blue bloods can maintain eliteness across several coaches:

Kansas - Brown, Williams, Self
UNC - Smith, Williams
Kentucky - Rupp, Smith, Calipari
UCLA - Wooden, Harrick

You'll notice that even these blue bloods will struggle from time to time with the wrong coach. Kentucky had Gillespie. UNC had Matt Doherty. UCLA had Lavin and Alford.

This evidence should lead us to believe that coaching is paramount to college bball success. UNC on the jersey means nothing when Matt Doherty is coaching. Indiana on the jersey means nothing when clappy CTC is coaching. Coaching hires, then, are the critical decision points that determine whether a program will be elite or not.

But elite coaches don't grow on trees. IU is now struggling with middling coaches like CTC and CAM. Much like UConn could not find another elite coach, and is now a bottom feeder, so too is IU a bottom feeder, not having found an elite coach.

Therefore, IU basketball is no longer an elite program. Change my mind.
 
Most elite basketball programs are simply the product of a single coach:

IU and Knight
Syracuse and Boeheim
UConn and Calhoun
Duke and Coach K
Michigan State and Izzo
Villanova and Wright
UVA and Bennett.

Only a few blue bloods can maintain eliteness across several coaches:

Kansas - Brown, Williams, Self
UNC - Smith, Williams
Kentucky - Rupp, Smith, Calipari
UCLA - Wooden, Harrick

You'll notice that even these blue bloods will struggle from time to time with the wrong coach. Kentucky had Gillespie. UNC had Matt Doherty. UCLA had Lavin and Alford.

This evidence should lead us to believe that coaching is paramount to college bball success. UNC on the jersey means nothing when Matt Doherty is coaching. Indiana on the jersey means nothing when clappy CTC is coaching. Coaching hires, then, are the critical decision points that determine whether a program will be elite or not.

But elite coaches don't grow on trees. IU is now struggling with middling coaches like CTC and CAM. Much like UConn could not find another elite coach, and is now a bottom feeder, so too is IU a bottom feeder, not having found an elite coach.

Therefore, IU basketball is no longer an elite program. Change my mind.
Facts are facts.
 
IU has not been elite in 30 years and likely never will be again. It is probably time we all accept the fact we have an administration that will never do what it take to be elite. I know I have started to come to grips with this finally.
Not going to accept that.
 
Most elite basketball programs are simply the product of a single coach:

IU and Knight
Syracuse and Boeheim
UConn and Calhoun
Duke and Coach K
Michigan State and Izzo
Villanova and Wright
UVA and Bennett.

Only a few blue bloods can maintain eliteness across several coaches:

Kansas - Brown, Williams, Self
UNC - Smith, Williams
Kentucky - Rupp, Smith, Calipari
UCLA - Wooden, Harrick

You'll notice that even these blue bloods will struggle from time to time with the wrong coach. Kentucky had Gillespie. UNC had Matt Doherty. UCLA had Lavin and Alford.

This evidence should lead us to believe that coaching is paramount to college bball success. UNC on the jersey means nothing when Matt Doherty is coaching. Indiana on the jersey means nothing when clappy CTC is coaching. Coaching hires, then, are the critical decision points that determine whether a program will be elite or not.

But elite coaches don't grow on trees. IU is now struggling with middling coaches like CTC and CAM. Much like UConn could not find another elite coach, and is now a bottom feeder, so too is IU a bottom feeder, not having found an elite coach.

Therefore, IU basketball is no longer an elite program. Change my mind.
We will be a basketball school as long as we have an educated fan base and stellar support from the fans. Calling for Archie to be replaced before his first recruiting class has finished one season shows a decrease in support caused from an increasingly uneducated sector of our fan base.

Glass says he fired Crean because we were not able to compete at a championship level. It took us a long time to reach the depths of where Tom Crean left the program. It will take more than a single class or one 5 star to correct 17 years of decline.

The will of the fans, and the AD if we can trust him, is there to return to national success. I just wish those that are running down the program would wait until there is a reason to moan, or jump to another bandwagon.

Root for PU or UK, i don't care. Just get out of the way. You can come back in 2 years when we have seen the results of Archie's influence.
 
IU has not been elite in 30 years and likely never will be again. It is probably time we all accept the fact we have an administration that will never do what it take to be elite. I know I have started to come to grips with this finally.
Heck, if Sampson wouldn’t have messed up (or IU just kept their mouth shut, depending on how you look at it), then they’d likely have another banner or two to hang in AH.
 
Actually its 3-1 but all of them were so long ago its not worth discussing.
Broilees banner at Mackey Arena-
Gallery_large39.jpg
 
Got money next year every network that carries us say's..
We have one of the blue bloods tonight ..
Hell UK isn't even getting Kentucky's Mr.basketball.
He's going to Xavier..
 
Just a slight correction - the NIT was the top post season tournament when iu won their first two NCAA championships. Winning the NCAA at that time was the equivalent of winning the NIT today.
Thanks for the correction.
 
The latest mind boggling stat to me is havent won 2 games in a big ten tournament in SIXTEEYEARS!

Worst record next to Northwestern all time.

Ohio State 27–15[note 2] .643 4 4
Michigan State 30–16 .652 5 1
Illinois 28–19 .596 2 4
Wisconsin 24–18 .571 3 4
Michigan 22–17[note 1] .564 2 1
Iowa 16–19 .457 2 1
Rutgers 3–5 .375 0 0
Minnesota 15–19[note 3] .441 0 1
Purdue 14–20 .412 1 3
Penn State 14–22 .389 0 1
Indiana 12–22 .353 0 1
Maryland 2–5 .286 0 0
Nebraska 5–7 .417 0 0
Northwestern 9–22 .290 0 0
 
It would take five or six years straight of bad results for that to happen. Indiana has one of the most loyal fan bases there is and people show up no matter what. I think you would probably have to miss the tournament for five or six straight years to see a half empty stadium. One of the reasons the admins do not care cause the place is still sold out.
Not sure about that. The number of fans who increasingly don't care as much is growing. Many of us no longer believe IU is an elite program.
 
Most elite basketball programs are simply the product of a single coach:

IU and Knight
Syracuse and Boeheim
UConn and Calhoun
Duke and Coach K
Michigan State and Izzo
Villanova and Wright
UVA and Bennett.

Only a few blue bloods can maintain eliteness across several coaches:

Kansas - Brown, Williams, Self
UNC - Smith, Williams
Kentucky - Rupp, Smith, Calipari
UCLA - Wooden, Harrick

You'll notice that even these blue bloods will struggle from time to time with the wrong coach. Kentucky had Gillespie. UNC had Matt Doherty. UCLA had Lavin and Alford.

This evidence should lead us to believe that coaching is paramount to college bball success. UNC on the jersey means nothing when Matt Doherty is coaching. Indiana on the jersey means nothing when clappy CTC is coaching. Coaching hires, then, are the critical decision points that determine whether a program will be elite or not.

But elite coaches don't grow on trees. IU is now struggling with middling coaches like CTC and CAM. Much like UConn could not find another elite coach, and is now a bottom feeder, so too is IU a bottom feeder, not having found an elite coach.

Therefore, IU basketball is no longer an elite program. Change my mind.
Sad times...seems like Administration doesn't want basketball to overshadow university ever again
 
It would take five or six years straight of bad results for that to happen. Indiana has one of the most loyal fan bases there is and people show up no matter what. I think you would probably have to miss the tournament for five or six straight years to see a half empty stadium. One of the reasons the admins do not care cause the place is still sold out.
We're getting close to that 5 year mark
 
Most elite basketball programs are simply the product of a single coach:

IU and Knight
Syracuse and Boeheim
UConn and Calhoun
Duke and Coach K
Michigan State and Izzo
Villanova and Wright
UVA and Bennett.

Only a few blue bloods can maintain eliteness across several coaches:

Kansas - Brown, Williams, Self
UNC - Smith, Williams
Kentucky - Rupp, Smith, Calipari
UCLA - Wooden, Harrick

You'll notice that even these blue bloods will struggle from time to time with the wrong coach. Kentucky had Gillespie. UNC had Matt Doherty. UCLA had Lavin and Alford.

This evidence should lead us to believe that coaching is paramount to college bball success. UNC on the jersey means nothing when Matt Doherty is coaching. Indiana on the jersey means nothing when clappy CTC is coaching. Coaching hires, then, are the critical decision points that determine whether a program will be elite or not.

But elite coaches don't grow on trees. IU is now struggling with middling coaches like CTC and CAM. Much like UConn could not find another elite coach, and is now a bottom feeder, so too is IU a bottom feeder, not having found an elite coach.

Therefore, IU basketball is no longer an elite program. Change my mind.
Historically, yes IU most certainly is. Currently though I would say we really are not and haven't been (with a few brief exceptions over the last 20 years or so). The fans are still there (among the most passionate in the country) and no fan base deserves success more. However, after years of ignorant hires coupled with the deemphasis of sports, we're stuck in mediocrity. The jury is still out on Miler but I am not at all impressed so far. I think we need an elite coach to get us back there and Fred likely won't be the guy to get us there.
 
Sad times...seems like Administration doesn't want basketball to overshadow university ever again
I do not know the posters here, but you are very close to getting this right with that post. The puppeteers behind the curtain have their very own club. They call the shots. You never see their names. Bob Knight was more powerful than they were. They hated him for that and they also were snowflakes, knowing virtually nothing about coaching or intellectual brilliance in coaching but they hated him for his public demeanor and the absence of his willingness to bow to them so they wanted a reason to get rid of him. At that time, the largest contributor to the university was a little lady in her 80s who barely knew there was an IU basketball team.

In any event, the happenings quite a few years before RMK was fired and, though perhaps to a lesser degree, to this day, turn on the public face of the university and the mystery people behind the scenes being unable or unwilling to support anything that might offend the sensibilities of the invisible leadership cloistered in the curtained parlors of the deepest recesses of the university. RMK was on the verge of reinventing the game and they had to find a reason to take him out or he was going to reclaim the power they so hated and hate today (though some of the names have changed).

The current operation is controlled by a group of timid insiders (timid about having anything embarass them or IU) who clap one another on the back in congratulations for the wonder that is IU and will make darned sure that the power never again escapes them. They want very good teams. They want to have some bragging rights, but they do not want the program to be more powerful than their group is. They sure do not have the personal makeup to abide a personality like Bob Knight. Remember, they brought RMK in from Army to establish discipline in a program that was on the precipice of NCAA punishment for the alumni shenanigans that had been going on for a while - think paying recruits and $100 handshakes in the locker room. Knight came in and threw those people out and kept them away from the program. They also hated that. They didn't know f he could coach. Army wasn't much. But they knew he'd get the NCAA off their back.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: IUgradman
yup, at least before we find someone like Coach Knight. Miller is not the guy. I think we all see that.
There is no such person to be found today. At least I can't think of any coach remotely like him, can you? In the politically correct environment of 2019?
 
There is no such person to be found today. At least I can't think of any coach remotely like him, can you? In the politically correct environment of 2019?
I can’t believe Archie did not take any raging technicals this year! More pressure from administration? Possibly. How could u not lose your mind at least once.
 
Let's be honest, the last team we had that even resembled anything of IU basketball and heart was coached by Mike Davis and as much as most of us (myself included) clamored for his firing, we probably should have rode with it
 
It would take five or six years straight of bad results for that to happen. Indiana has one of the most loyal fan bases there is and people show up no matter what. I think you would probably have to miss the tournament for five or six straight years to see a half empty stadium. One of the reasons the admins do not care cause the place is still sold out.
It won't take that long …. they're mindful of the brand name too, merchandising, etc.
 
It won't take that long …. they're mindful of the brand name too, merchandising, etc.
How many 16-17 year old kids (when you begin recruiting them) care or even know of RMK's legacy here and what was a great and feared program? Sure 5 banners, the first one 80 years ago.
 
Let's be honest, the last team we had that even resembled anything of IU basketball and heart was coached by Mike Davis and as much as most of us (myself included) clamored for his firing, we probably should have rode with it
Yep Davis would have done fine at IU that was really stupid, plus he’s a freaking great Christian dude.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT