When the 10th St stadium was torn down in 1981, it was not at all apparent what IU's soccer program was going to become. This was just a few years removed from the athletic department not funding the soccer team's first final four appearance (it was funded through private donations). It would have been ludicrous at the time to spend huge money to renovate the stadium, and would have required a crystal ball of epic proportions. It was pretty impressive that IU built Armstrong Stadium for such a fledgling team (in a sport that was thought to be a fad nationally) and a once a year intramural event. And the cost of Armstrong would have been a tiny fraction of what would have been needed for the 10th street stadium renovation. Plus, this forethought would have also needed to extend back to before the soccer program was a varsity sport at IU, when it was decided not to maintain the stadium, which allowed it to fall into such disrepair. Deferred maintenance can easily increase the cost of repairs 3-4 fold.
no offense to Armstrong, but that venue isn't even in the same galaxy as what a renovated 10th st stadium would have been, in addition to the fact that Armstrong is out of site, out of mind, while the old stadium was on by then a bustling part of the main campus.
none of us know the real numbers on renovating the stadium.
and those numbers get skewed depending on whether those coming up with them want the project or don't want it.
like i said, "too expensive" is political speak for , "we don't want to do it".
and tearing it down and contouring/landscaping that area had a cost too.
they knew in 81 that soccer was a growing thing.
that said, my post wasn't about just what renovating 10th st MS would do for soccer, but also, probably moreso, what it would have done for that section of campus.
the "cool fact" of the arboretum pales in comparison to the cool factor of walking between 7th and 10th and looking into to open end of the horseshoe, and seeing athletic teams practicing/playing in there.
if you didn't go to IU back when even just the bikers practiced in there every spring, you'll never get what i'm talking about, because you'll never have the point of reference of walking past and looking into the open end of the horseshoe.