ADVERTISEMENT

OT: What should the NFL decide to do?

Because KC will be #1 seed at 14-3, Buffalo #2 at 13-3 (if they win today).

But if Buffalo had beaten Cincinnati they would have been the #1 seed over KC due to a tiebreaker. Both 14-3.

So the 16 vs. 17 games played screwed the Bills from having a shot at #1 seed and a bye. If they were to meet in the conference finals, to not have them be double screwed, any KC-Buffalo game will be at a neutral site.
If they're going to play the what if game, what if Cincinnati had beaten Buffalo? Cincinnati would host if they meet. They have opened a can that raises alot of questions that can't/won't be answered. Makes me think the decision makers are the same ones that handled the 2020 BIG.
 
Cincinnati definitely got screwed the most. Potentially having to go to Buffalo, and even to Baltimore is they (Cin) lose today and lose a coin flip.

All solutions would have screwed someone.
 
If they're going to play the what if game, what if Cincinnati had beaten Buffalo? Cincinnati would host if they meet. They have opened a can that raises alot of questions that can't/won't be answered. Makes me think the decision makers are the same ones that handled the 2020 BIG.

Yep, and the part that annoys me is it is exactly like the B10, the NFL has a rule to use winning % if a situation like this develops it. They voted to change the rule. Why have a rule if you just vote to change it once it looks like it will go in effect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: larsIU
The NFL indeed has a rule to use winning % if a situation like this develops.

They voted to KEEP that rule for all playoff seeding and match-ups.

They then also (unwisely, imo) made a new ruling on home field vs neutral, just for teams directly affected by the missed game, and added a coin flip for a potential Ravens-Bengals matchup.
 
The NFL indeed has a rule to use winning % if a situation like this develops.

They voted to KEEP that rule for all playoff seeding and match-ups.

They then also (unwisely, imo) made a new ruling on home field vs neutral, just for teams directly affected by the missed game, and added a coin flip for a potential Ravens-Bengals matchup.

Right. They added an addendum to the normal rule. The old rule meant the Bengals could not get the 1 seed, fine, no complaints, that's the rule, winning percentage determines that. But the addendum means the Bengals lose today and win % does not matter and it is a coin toss.

It is like 1981 in MLB where the Reds had the best record in baseball but not allowed in the playoffs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: outside shooter
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT