Huge recruiting losses? Kids have many choices of where to play. Expecting every one to attend IU isn't realistic. Painter rarely gets a top recruit. He relies on grad transfers and the second and third tier players. That is the method of someone that doesn't have the ability to recruit elite talent to make their roster competitive. It works for them, but we can do better.
I'll take a transfer if it is a player we would have wanted as a freshman or if we have an open scholarship and they are okay as a role player or having limited playing time. Brunk was a good use of a grad transfer. We had a need and he was someone we had done our homework on and had been able to see play.
We have not lost a game this year due to the lack of a PG or depth. I get it. Archie wasn't your guy. Now that he is here, understand that he is building for the long term and a sense of urgency brings in players like Crean recruited. I like having a mix of solid experience and the burger boys. If TJD leaves early, we will have options available if we need them or Archie may feel good about what we already have committed. I'm not going to worry about next year. I believe TJD will stay, get stronger, work on his right hand, and work on his range. If not, I'm sure Archie has a plan. It won't be a panicked reaction to fill the roster with crap.
Eleven games in, we are 10-1. I'm sure we will lose a few games to give a thrill to you guys wanting to be proven correct. The reality is that most coaches fail at some point and are fired. If you keep complaining and stick with your desire to be correct regardless of the effect on the program, someday you might be able to tell us how smart you were in 2019. I see beyond a bad game at Wisconsin and a difficult game against a team that destroyed a comparable team 2 days later. I'm not wishing Archie to fail like so many are.
Actually, Archie WAS my guy. It looked like it was between Holtmann, Mack & Archie and, on the face of things, he looked like the right call.
When I saw his press conference, it was like "ok, he's nervous...not outgoing, but at least he'll be one fierce sob". Well......., not so much, as far as I can tell after 3 years. Where is the determination and the fight? And I don't see it being made up by being superior on the Xs and Os. He seems very average in that regard. It seems to me that TJD is carrying his water. Do you see otherwise?
And yes, losing Carton & Garcia were huge recruiting losses. And since Carton, he is in the 0-8 to 0-10 range on recruiting another pg. Then there was taking Damezi over Henry, and re-recruiting Al, Smith & Cliff Moore. Brunk was a good add. Fitzner was a good try, IF we did our due diligence in recruiting him. If we would have known with good scouting and investigation that he was as mentally & physically soft as he turned out to be.....not so much.
Comparing Painter to Archie on recruiting isn't fair to Painter. He's not going to get a Romeo out of Southern Indiana or a TJD out of Indy. IU, for now at least, still has the cachet Purdue lacks.
So right now the minuses outnumber the pluses, and by a long-shot, imo. What about this year? The last 2 of our 7 automatic wins were concerning.......then FSU. Breakthrough? Then crap games v. Wisconsin & Nebraska. So.....4 of the last 5 games have been poor efforts.