This I agree with. Americans would never tolerate the draconian measures required to contain a severe outbreak in the way that the Chinese and many other countries can implement. Plus, Americans have a certain arrogance about them that gets in the way of voluntarily locking themselves down. Everyone sees themselves and their own endeavors as "too important" to be interrupted.
That said, I think some of the more dire prognostications (such as the one linked by Cream&Crimson above) are probably a tad over the top. But who knows?
If any of you have been to China, its not the obvious 'police state' that most people who have never been there think it is. Same as Singapore. f
The difference between the two countries, in terms of responses to the Coronavirus outbreak/epidemic, is the difference of decisiveness and timelines.
The only reason why China took such a draconian solution of complete lockdown is simply that they waited way too long before responding. The slower the response, the more draconian the solution.
My daily life has not changed one iota here in Singapore. I did see fewer people on the streets or in the subways. (Actually its getting back to almost normal this week in terms of crowds.) They banned flights back in January.
Then track, mapped and isolated the 1st level contacts. Then managed the secondary contacts. Teams were in place -- from the pandemic playbook (lessons learnt from SARs) to tracing teams to getting the police involved in tracking 2nd level suspects to teams managing the food delivery for the secondary contacts home isolation.
In parallel, there has to be a communication and education programme from the gov't. The do's and don'ts. The need for self-responsibility is.
All this talk about ''freedom'' etc only highlights the shallowness of the concept of patriotism. Being American is supposed to entail concern for other fellow Americans.
If people dont give a feck about one another, you wonder why all that kneeling by a football player is so upsetting? Instead they are willing to die for some 'innate' object like a flag or a song instead of real people?
Arrogance is another issue. There are countries who have been in the frontline for months now. The idea of lessons learnt doesnt seem to come into play at all. They seem to think that everything is a uniquely American experience and therefore, requires the Americans to save the world, just like in the movies.
Edit:
Italy planning to quarantine entire Lombardy region
Italy plans to quarantine the entire Lombardy region – an area that includes the nation’s financial hub Milan – as well as Venice, in the most severe escalation of coronavirus-prevention measures to be taken outside of China.
Under a draft decree published by the Italian government, citizens will be unable to leave or enter the Lombardy region, while similar restrictions are extended in established “red zones” including Venice, Parma and Modena.
It came as:
- The respiratory illness spread to more than 90 countries, killing more than 3,400 people and infecting more than 100,000 worldwide.
- Cases in the UK rose to 209, with the family of the second person to die in the country after contracting the virus describing self-isolating as they attempted to grieve a “nightmare”
- Italian doctors warned medics across Europe to “get ready” while claiming a high percentage of cases are being admitted to intensive care
The Lombardy, Veneto and Emilia Romagna regions represented 85 per cent of national cases and 92 per cent of the total 233 deaths confirmed in the country – however, cases have been recorded in each of the nation’s 20 regions, while deaths have been confirmed in eight of them.
The result has also had a knock-on effect on the Italian economy, with Rome pledging €7.5bn (£6.4bn) to tackle the consequences of the virus.
Like, the longer you take to start controlling the spread, the more draconian measures will be required.
Last edited: