If you always passed on players of that caliber and from Indiana, you wouldn't be coach for very longI see some logic in your statement and I think it is easily supportable, which inclines me to believe you are right.
As for me, I would just as soon leave Romeo alone because he's likely a one-and-done and, while I don't disagree with those players, that doesn't mean I would recruit them into my program, if I were a coach. But, I think signing him is a sign to these other players who will make a difference in the future.