Mexico v Smith and Wesson

[CO. Hoosier]

Arguments today in Supreme Court.

In short: Mexico sued Smith and Wesson because of the horrendous amount of guns in the hands of the Cartels resulting in thousands and thousands of deaths.

Federal immunity law protects s&W. An exception is if S&W knowingly violates a law proximately related to the ultimate third party crime. Mexico says S&W knows it sells to gun runners. S&W says that’s not facially illegal.

For those of you who have been here awhile know I dislike the immunity law, as I do most all immunity laws. (I think they violate the 7th Amendment). Moreover, I think we need decent and effective gun control laws.

Oral arguments today and even the liberal justices were poking holes in Mexicos case.

Mexico is gonna lose. Nice try though.

Congress needs to fix this.

Supreme Court seems ready to block Mexican government's lawsuit against U.S. gunmakers

The Supreme Court is considering the Mexican government's effort to hold U.S. gun companies accountable for violence involving trafficked firearms.

www.cbsnews.com

 

[The Original Happy Goat]

Mexico says S&W knows it sells to gun runners. S&W says that’s not facially illegal.

This part confuses me.

 

[hookyIU1990]

What does congress have to fix? It sounds like the ATF should be in some retailers that are known to be selling guns to straw purchasers.

 

[mcmurtry66]

Arguments today in Supreme Court.

In short: Mexico sued Smith and Wesson because of the horrendous amount of guns in the hands of the Cartels resulting in thousands and thousands of deaths.

Federal immunity law protects s&W. An exception is if S&W knowingly violates a law proximately related to the ultimate third party crime. Mexico says S&W knows it sells to gun runners. S&W says that’s not facially illegal.

For those of you who have been here awhile know I dislike the immunity law, as I do most all immunity laws. (I think they violate the 7th Amendment). Moreover, I think we need decent and effective gun control laws.

Oral arguments today and even the liberal justices were poking holes in Mexicos case.

Mexico is gonna lose. Nice try though.

Congress needs to fix this.

Supreme Court seems ready to block Mexican government's lawsuit against U.S. gunmakers

The Supreme Court is considering the Mexican government's effort to hold U.S. gun companies accountable for violence involving trafficked firearms.

www.cbsnews.com

Loser argument. The path to success is prescribed by tobacco. Advertising practices etc. seems the only viable path in these cases

 

[Spartans9312]

Arguments today in Supreme Court.

In short: Mexico sued Smith and Wesson because of the horrendous amount of guns in the hands of the Cartels resulting in thousands and thousands of deaths.

Federal immunity law protects s&W. An exception is if S&W knowingly violates a law proximately related to the ultimate third party crime. Mexico says S&W knows it sells to gun runners. S&W says that’s not facially illegal.

For those of you who have been here awhile know I dislike the immunity law, as I do most all immunity laws. (I think they violate the 7th Amendment). Moreover, I think we need decent and effective gun control laws.

Oral arguments today and even the liberal justices were poking holes in Mexicos case.

Mexico is gonna lose. Nice try though.

Congress needs to fix this.

Supreme Court seems ready to block Mexican government's lawsuit against U.S. gunmakers

The Supreme Court is considering the Mexican government's effort to hold U.S. gun companies accountable for violence involving trafficked firearms.

www.cbsnews.com

If they don’t uphold immunity claims….American gun rights will disappear because manufacturers and firearms dealers will be sued into oblivion

Next up…Bourbon distillers will be held liable for drunk-driving deaths