I hear what you are saying. Without certain intangibles that I believe are incredibly important, I can understand your point that apparently identical players, one from this state and one from another seem to be a tossup.And that's great - but the fact that a kid is from Indiana or not from Indiana has absolutely nothing to do with winning basketball games or roster building or any of it.
But the intangibles that you may be disregarding are the ones that I believe put the identically appearing Indiana high school recruit ahead in most cases. They are:
1. Family and friends and fans of the Indiana high school recruit can more easily get to the games and/or otherwise support the recruit at Indiana;
2. Building a relationship with many or all of the Indiana high school coaches and recruiting their top players builds good will in the state and in each of the gyms around the state.
3. Knowing the Indiana University traditions, history, academics, including but not limited to POTFBs are a way to help build comradery.
4. Locking down the state recruits builds an almost never ending pipeline to the roster at Indiana University.
Looking at the way Archie Miller is building the roster one may or may not see the advantages of State of Indiana recruiting and recruits. But I do. I appreciate that an Indiana high school recruit is much more likely to go to Indiana than essentially an equivalent university in...say...Toledo. And all of the above will likely indirectly impact winnings favorably.
You don't see it. That is cool.
Archie see it...apparently.