ADVERTISEMENT

Transfer Portal Targets

Bringing in Noland would likely cause at least one current QB on the roster to leave. Whatever, to me the only probable “difference-maker” imo that’s been connected to IU is the older Mendoza, and I get the impression that he might end up at UGA or hometown Miami. I just don’t view Pribula as being in that same category. I see him as being in the same category as Jackson.

If anything I’m more concerned with IU’s non-QB recruiting than the potential QBs they might bring in. Losing Hopper to a G5 school was disappointing, and I think they still definitely need at least one legitimate edge rusher (Lawson from UL is another interior guy). I would also like to see at least one more WR sign, as well as multiple OLs. And it would be a huge get if they could sign Maldonado.
EDIT: Dawson from UL, not Lawson. Similar in build to Wheeler and Ratcliff
 
  • Like
Reactions: red hornet and 76-1
I’m not a big Pribula guy, but then I’m kind of an “Allar skeptic” to begin with and if Pribula can’t beat out Allar then I’m not that excited.

If Cig and Shanahan like him, fair enough. Personally I’d probably prefer Noland (I’m not counting on Mendoza at this point).
I read on a OSU forum some talk that Noland's issues early got him behind the others, missed class or missed workouts. Others heard good things.

Anyway, the comment I liked was
"... met Air at a special needs football camp last summer. He was sooo nice to the athletes there, and threw passes at the station I worked for over an hour. The athletes loved him, and he stayed until the last person got a selfie or an autograph from him. I hope he balls out somewhere. "

Gotta like doing good things for special needs kids.

Somebody else wondered if he'd go to Indiana. On the elevenwarriors free forum.
,
 
Last edited:
Some info:




I'll trust Shanahan and Cig. They believe they can get plenty out of him apparently. He adds depth. Depends on the price maybe, balancing the NIL, but seems good.

Cig is zagging when last year he zigged. ('Cigged'? )
Every coach out there has heard 'production over potential' , that made a team 11-1 ... Some of this years targets seem to be more 'potential'. Moneyball. Gotta throw some change ups!

Some RS freshman type targets may be more affordable than when they were highly prized high school recruits, plus you have them a year stronger. Some others like Nowakowski may be affordable depth but our coaches see a good fit where he can shine.

Glad Nowakowski is coming to the Hoosiers!
,
 
  • Like
Reactions: red hornet
FWIW: one site lists a 6’ 6” 305 lb OL from UK as being in the portal. Name is Dylan Ray iirc, and he’s apparently from Noblesville, IN. I don’t know if Allen’s staff recruited him out of high school or not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 76-1 and red hornet
I’m not a big Pribula guy, but then I’m kind of an “Allar skeptic” to begin with and if Pribula can’t beat out Allar then I’m not that excited.

If Cig and Shanahan like him, fair enough. Personally I’d probably prefer Noland (I’m not counting on Mendoza at this point).
So, counterpoint:
You take a guy like Air Noland, who was something like the #5 QB in the 2023 class. Has spent two seasons with OSU. Highly rated. He was 4th or 5th (by some preseason charts) on their depth chart. Behind guys like Will Howard and Devin Brown. If Allat is overrated, my take is Howard is too. I didn’t think he was that great. Got a lot of hype but was terrible against Michigan in a huge game. I think we end up with either Mendoza, Pribula or possibly Nolan and I think Cig could do well with all 3. Pribula has a lot of instinct when you watch him play. He visited Missouri and has visits lined up to Iowa, UCF and IU. There are actually teams out there that like his game.
 
So, counterpoint:
You take a guy like Air Noland, who was something like the #5 QB in the 2023 class. Has spent two seasons with OSU. Highly rated. He was 4th or 5th (by some preseason charts) on their depth chart. Behind guys like Will Howard and Devin Brown. If Allat is overrated, my take is Howard is too. I didn’t think he was that great. Got a lot of hype but was terrible against Michigan in a huge game. I think we end up with either Mendoza, Pribula or possibly Nolan and I think Cig could do well with all 3. Pribula has a lot of instinct when you watch him play. He visited Missouri and has visits lined up to Iowa, UCF and IU. There are actually teams out there that like his game.
As I said, the only one who excites me much would be Mendoza, but I don’t feel particularly confident about him ending up in Bloomington. And I’m more concerned about some other positions right now than I am about QB.
 
I'll trust Shanahan and Cig. They believe they can get plenty out of him apparently. He adds depth. Depends on the price maybe, balancing the NIL, but seems good.

Cig is zagging when last year he zigged. ('Cigged'? )
Every coach out there has heard 'production over potential' , that made a team 11-1 ... Some of this years targets seem to be more 'potential'. Moneyball. Gotta throw some change ups!

Some RS freshman type targets may be more affordable than when they were highly prized high school recruits, plus you have them a year stronger. Some others like Nowakowski may be affordable depth but our coaches see a good fit where he can shine.

Glad Nowakowski is coming to the Hoosiers!
,
It’s very rare to get a black guy playing TE with a white kid’s first name and a Polish last name. I’ll take it! Good pickup from a veteran standpoint. This will be his 5th year in college.
 
As I said, the only one who excites me much would be Mendoza, but I don’t feel particularly confident about him ending up in Bloomington. And I’m more concerned about some other positions right now than I am about QB.
Cig has done well with whoever her puts back there. I trust whoever it is next season won’t be a slouch.
Everyone was concerned going into the 2024 season because “all Cig did was bring in a bunch of G5 players” and all the pundits said “you cannot win” with transfers from JMU, Old Dominion, Ohio, Kent State, etc.
 
Cig has done well with whoever her puts back there. I trust whoever it is next season won’t be a slouch.
Everyone was concerned going into the 2024 season because “all Cig did was bring in a bunch of G5 players” and all the pundits said “you cannot win” with transfers from JMU, Old Dominion, Ohio, Kent State, etc.
I’m OK with Wheeler and Ratcliff, but they’re not edge guys. I would’ve been ok with Hopper too but Tulane apparently got him instead. So far no edge guys have signed, or at least it hasn’t been announced. That’s the concern, not what other programs they played at before IU.

Same with OLs. Need more of them signing as well. I’m hoping for some news on these positions soon.
 
I’m OK with Wheeler and Ratcliff, but they’re not edge guys. I would’ve been ok with Hopper too but Tulane apparently got him instead. So far no edge guys have signed, or at least it hasn’t been announced. That’s the concern, not what other programs they played at before IU.

Same with OLs. Need more of them signing as well. I’m hoping for some news on these positions soon.
Maybe that is an indication that Kamara is coming back?
 
So, counterpoint:
You take a guy like Air Noland, who was something like the #5 QB in the 2023 class. Has spent two seasons with OSU. Highly rated. He was 4th or 5th (by some preseason charts) on their depth chart. Behind guys like Will Howard and Devin Brown. If Allat is overrated, my take is Howard is too. I didn’t think he was that great. Got a lot of hype but was terrible against Michigan in a huge game. I think we end up with either Mendoza, Pribula or possibly Nolan and I think Cig could do well with all 3. Pribula has a lot of instinct when you watch him play. He visited Missouri and has visits lined up to Iowa, UCF and IU. There are actually teams out there that like his game.
Air Noland is a true freshman. He hasn’t been at osu 2 seasons. With 5 star Julian Sayin in the same class and all the hype surrounding St. Clair Noland seems to be the odd man out. However, it doesn’t feel like we are a realistic option. I could be wrong, but our strong pursuit of other QBs makes me doubt he is coming to IU. I wouldn’t mind seeing it happen though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bucket Getter
Air Noland is a true freshman. He hasn’t been at osu 2 seasons. With 5 star Julian Sayin in the same class and all the hype surrounding St. Clair Noland seems to be the odd man out. However, it doesn’t feel like we are a realistic option. I could be wrong, but our strong pursuit of other QBs makes me doubt he is coming to IU. I wouldn’t mind seeing it happen though.
Production over Potential
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bucket Getter
I’ve been wondering if there is any interest in Karlaftis. He is certainly not his brother, but he has some talent and a lot of Big10 experience

An Emphatic No... (on Karlaftis)

Not only is he a puke... He's far too sllloooowww... He was too slow when they signed him (5.2), and he's still too slow...

The only reason he ended up playing Big Ten ball was because of his brothers legacy and the fact that p u is full of dumbs--es in football decision making rolls...
 
Last edited:
This account has been right before. This would be a huge get at RB

I think Lee Beebe is the guy and this looks like a solid #2. Both can receive the ball although Hemby seems like that was a larger part of his game. I don't know anything about his blocking, but he has lots of experience.

Just to point out the other side of this, if you take out that 75-yard run vs IU, he wouldn't have had any game over 87 yds. Only one game over 67yds and he got double digit rushes in 9 of the 12 games. His average also drops down to 4ypc if you take out that 75yd rush.

Anyways, I think he is a veteran player with lots of experience and fits the mold of what Cig did last year with our backfield. Solid productive pickup!
 
...

Just to point out the other side of this, if you take out that 75-yard run vs IU, he wouldn't have had any game over 87 yds. Only one game over 67yds and he got double digit rushes in 9 of the 12 games. His average also drops down to 4ypc if you take out that 75yd rush.
...
Downer! :oops:

Good points. Looks well rounded though. I like his wheels, he hits the hole fast. And those long runs count. Derrick Henry will go 12 for 34, then 13 for 104 ...
,
 
Downer! :oops:

Good points. Looks well rounded though. I like his wheels, he hits the hole fast. And those long runs count. Derrick Henry will go 12 for 34, then 13 for 104 ...
,
He did much better his freshman year though. So as another poster said, this could just be OL related. He's got some size, speed and hands to go along with a lot of experience for a true freshman RB. Its a really good get, I didn't mean to overly poo poo it. ha Sorry!
 
Shhhhhhhhh!!!! I think this is one Cig's main secrets to his early success at IU. And I suspect it will guide him going forward. I've championed this approach for years on the bball board.

Its easier in basketball, because you only have to fill a few spots every year. But one of the first filters I'd have when sifting through who to go after the hardest, on the recruiting trail...championships and personal awards. Conference championships, State championships, mental attitude awards, all conference, all state, AAU tournament championships...

In short...distinguish winners and achievers from the sea of talent.
That is exactly what I said in a letter to DiNardo years ago, his reply
was, I know what you mean, not that I had any idea what I was talking
about. lol
 
Air Noland is a true freshman. He hasn’t been at osu 2 seasons. With 5 star Julian Sayin in the same class and all the hype surrounding St. Clair Noland seems to be the odd man out. However, it doesn’t feel like we are a realistic option. I could be wrong, but our strong pursuit of other QBs makes me doubt he is coming to IU. I wouldn’t mind seeing it happen though.
I stand corrected. You’re right. Noland committed in 2023 and enrolled in January 2024.
 
  • Like
Reactions: red hornet
That is exactly what I said in a letter to DiNardo years ago, his reply
was, I know what you mean, not that I had any idea what I was talking
about. lol
Our hockey coach up here Joe Shawan, at Michigan Tech is big on players who were team captains in high school, had a lot of success, etc.

That's fine as far as it goes. But now we have character but less talent and fewer wins... then we did when previous coach was here and recruited higher end skill. But then again previous Coach Mel Pearson flamed out at Michigan for various sins.

But anyway, I preferred talent. But I know they aren't exclusive. Cig seems to find both.
,
 
I think Lee Beebe is the guy and this looks like a solid #2. Both can receive the ball although Hemby seems like that was a larger part of his game. I don't know anything about his blocking, but he has lots of experience.

Just to point out the other side of this, if you take out that 75-yard run vs IU, he wouldn't have had any game over 87 yds. Only one game over 67yds and he got double digit rushes in 9 of the 12 games. His average also drops down to 4ypc if you take out that 75yd rush.

Anyways, I think he is a veteran player with lots of experience and fits the mold of what Cig did last year with our backfield. Solid productive pickup!
Bad offensive line and you may be reading too far into numbers. Big gains count. Tevin Coleman was the ultimate 12 carries for 35 yards, and 1 for 73.
 
Bad offensive line and you may be reading too far into numbers. Big gains count. Tevin Coleman was the ultimate 12 carries for 35 yards, and 1 for 73.
No I am not disregarding a player who often gets big yardage. If I took Tevin Colemans longest rush though, his stats would hardly change, because he did that a lot. ha The problem I was pointing out was that one rush for Hemby was his 2nd highest GAME total in rushing yards. :)

Either way, I later stated the OL does have an impact because his freshman year was better.
 
No I am not disregarding a player who often gets big yardage. If I took Tevin Colemans longest rush though, his stats would hardly change, because he did that a lot. ha The problem I was pointing out was that one rush for Hemby was his 2nd highest GAME total in rushing yards. :)

Either way, I later stated the OL does have an impact because his freshman year was better.
No I understood your point. I just get the feeling in this offense, it’s plug and play. It would be really hard to have a bad year. Our 4th string guy who didn’t play in 4? games had 200 yards and 5 TDs. Really would have liked to see what he could have done over a full season next year.
 
No I am not disregarding a player who often gets big yardage. If I took Tevin Colemans longest rush though, his stats would hardly change, because he did that a lot. ha The problem I was pointing out was that one rush for Hemby was his 2nd highest GAME total in rushing yards. :)

Either way, I later stated the OL does have an impact because his freshman year was better.
That’s why you take a guy like Hemby. You run power with Beebe for 5, 8, 6, 5 yards on consecutive plays and then bam…you have a home run guy bust it the next play. Guys like Ashton Jeanty are a rare breed these days, most schools go RB by committee and it’s good to have a variety of skill sets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IUgradman
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT