ADVERTISEMENT

M*A*S*H*, TV, and morality

Would "It's a Wonderful Life" be construed as sending a political message? Say it came out this year. Same movie.


PS. I 100% think "It's a Wonderful Life" sends a pretty ham fisted political message and I'm ok with that.

“one almost feels sorry for the cramped, reductive worldview evidenced by Jackson in her hypothetical, which seeks to deconstruct the universal through a crude racialist lens.”
 
  • Like
Reactions: DANC

“one almost feels sorry for the cramped, reductive worldview evidenced by Jackson in her hypothetical, which seeks to deconstruct the universal through a crude racialist lens.”
My favorite part of that article is this:

"These comments speak to Capra’s own expansive and magnanimous view of humanity. “When I see a crowd, I see a collection of free individuals: each a unique person; each a king or a queen; each a story that would fill a book; each an island of human dignity,” he once said. Of his choice of film subjects, he said, “Yes, let others make films about the grand sweeps of history. I’d make mine about the bloke that pushes the broom.”"

I'd rather watch a really well-made movie about the broom pusher than any king or queen.
 
My favorite part of that article is this:

"These comments speak to Capra’s own expansive and magnanimous view of humanity. “When I see a crowd, I see a collection of free individuals: each a unique person; each a king or a queen; each a story that would fill a book; each an island of human dignity,” he once said. Of his choice of film subjects, he said, “Yes, let others make films about the grand sweeps of history. I’d make mine about the bloke that pushes the broom.”"

I'd rather watch a really well-made movie about the broom pusher than any king or queen.
But broom pushers in Westeros? Chef’s kiss.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon_6hv78pr714xta
Take a look at Josey Wales, an honorable man hunted down by the evil government.

1930s had bankers in disrepute in the US. How many westerns are a banker, or big landowner, the evil-doer stopped by the lone-wolf (a very populist message)? I love Ford westerns, but Fort Apache was sending a message


As were his others.

Since this came up about MASH, MASH never said "Vote Democratic". It did mention Truman a couple times, once where Hawkeye sent him a telegram asking "who's responsible" and once where Potter is trying to trick a racist officer by blaming Truman for the desegregation of the army. Largely of course MASH was on Vietnam and couldn't blame the GOP for Vietnam and didn't try. But it did tackle racism, It certainly tackled the loneliness of service personnel. It certainly taught respect for everyone. Are those not fairly universal?
The Outlaw Josey Wales is one of the greatest films. It is so quotable. I absolutely love the speech Josey said to Ten Bears. "Governments don't live together. People do, and we don't have to go around butchering one another. You give me life and I give you life". Lots of truth. It's why I value local communities far more than what goes on in Washington.
 
"These comments speak to Capra’s own expansive and magnanimous view of humanity. “When I see a crowd, I see a collection of free individuals: each a unique person; each a king or a queen; each a story that would fill a book; each an island of human dignity,” he once said. Of his choice of film subjects, he said, “Yes, let others make films about the grand sweeps of history. I’d make mine about the bloke that pushes the broom.”"
I believe social media has elevated the individual above the community. And while Capra is right, I feel like the current generation of young people is ONLY focusing on the bolded.

And I hate it with every fiber of my being

I am writing this on an internet message board so I'm not without hypocrisy.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT