Between 02-04, DiNardo’s classes were ranked 81, 59, 59 (avg 66th)
Between 05-06, Heps classes were ranked 72, 84 (avg 78th)
Between 07-10, BL’s classes were ranked 97, 78, 59, 92 (avg. 82nd)
Between 11-16, CKW classes were ranked 59, 67, 38, 38, 49, 54 (avg. 51st)
Even taking out BL’s first class, it’s still 76th, so blaming recruiting is a false narrative. All of his top talent was gone the year he left so 2011 was going to be a rebuild regardless.
BL was 3-21 in the B1G his last 3 years at IU. Then you look at the fact that IU had more balanced schedules as there was no divisions while BL was coach. The first divisions (leaders vs legends) began in CKW’s first year, where Ohio State, Penn State, Wisconsin (was really good then) were in IU’s division. It seems slightly more balanced than the current east/west split but UM wasn't good then, and they thought Nebraska would be good so back then it was just as unbalanced. BL had every opportunity to succeed, and he just fell short in every category.
He was 30-34 at Ball State over his 8-year coaching career there. His first two years he was over .500. His last five years there he never broke .500 and within those 5 years he had back-to-back seasons of 1-10 followed by 0-11. After IU he went to D3 DePauw who was in the D3 playoffs before BL arrived in 09 and 10. Lynch was there from 2013-2019 (w/no playoffs) then in 21 and 22 they were back in the playoffs again. Coincidental? Again, super nice guy who can throw gum with the best of them but not a great head coach.