ADVERTISEMENT

Indiana/Ohio State Prediction Thread

It wasn’t depth that got us.
They beat us up front in the 2nd half
Not so sure - probably not - that OSU still has an advantage with their OL vs Indy's DL with them losing their starting LT and Center for the remainder of the year just in the last week or so. And their OL was already the weak link on their team. This could be interesting
Woa, IU is not Indy! Maybe just a typo??
The depth OSU has allows rotation of players with less falloff in size and talent. My point is with more depth a team stays fresher in the 2nd half and that’s what happened with Michigan
 
OSU 31
Indiana 17
I think we come out strong in the first half, but offense stalls in the second against a talented secondary and long Buckeye offensive drives wear our defense down. Basically what happened against Michigan but add in a capable offense. Hope I’m wrong. Go Hoosiers!
 
  • Like
Reactions: IUgradman
O$U 31
IU 21

The Michigan game was illuminating and showed that IU lacks elite talent. Cig is a better coach but the talent disparity is too much to overcome.
 
I think IU’s OL rebounds having played Michigan’s top level DL talent and Rourke stays upright.
WRs limit the drops, and Rourke recaptures the magic.
Howard gets harried enough, and Haines gets the defense off the field.

IU 38 — O$U 24
 
My fear exactly. Size, strength and depth will wear us down in the second half. Hopefully we’ll overcome the advantage OSU has up front but imo if we lose it will be in the trenches.
IU has its deepest front seven in years. The DL rotation keeps getting the job done, and should have an advantage v. a rebuilt O$U OL. Getting tired won’t be why IU loses. Winning the TO battle will be the bigger question.
 
I am bullish. I truly believe that we will win, even though it would be a big upset. We have to score early, and we can't let them get ahead and pin back their ears on D as we pass every down to try and catch up. Their C getting hurt is a big development and could be a huge story if our D controls the line of scrimmage. Rourke plays out of his mind and throws 4 TD's. We get a big special teams play. Our D has a critical 4th down stop and also forces a pick with their constant pressure on the QB.

Hoosiers 34
Buckeyes 31
I hope you're correct.

OSU 27
Indiana 20.
OSU starts out 27-0, then second half Indiana comes back only to throw it away with 3 minutes remaining. OSU holds on for win.
 
One suggestion, guys. There is a wide range of possible outcomes at the 'shoe this weekend and Saturday's game, for me, is the toughest pick since the UCLA game. I know there's a temptation, particularly this week, to go with "my heart says [Score A] but my head says [Score B]." Your call as to whether to go with your head or your heart, but try to go with just one score prediction. Let's have some fun with this and see who among us is Nostradamus.

Here's my prediction:

IU 27
OSU 23

Go Hoosiers!

95e67b35ad67aa897fb2a362383eb56b.jpg
 
  • Haha
Reactions: red hornet
Well, I've seen enough. I'm reversing my prediction. This INDY team is loaded. INDY 34 - OSU 21

Go Indy Hoosiers - beat those crooked Buckeyes
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: red hornet
ugh. The bell curve is it's just as likely we L by +20. as it is get a W.

*this started out short and grew and grew.... humor me.

Stats are very comparable however there as a couple of stand outs, specifically OSU's defense.

Red Zone

IU RZ Scoring %97.92% (#1)Opp RZ Scoring %85.71% (#73)OSU RZ Scoring %97.37% (#2)Opp RZ Scoring %52.17% (#1)

Passing yards per game and Sacks
IU Pass Yards/Game265.2 (#30)Opp Pass Yards/Game191.6 (#27)OSU Pass Yards/Game267.6 (#27)Opp Pass Yards/Game160.1 (#5)
IU Int Thrown %1.95% (#36)Opp Int Thrown %3.08% (#45)OSU Int Thrown %1.75% (#21)Opp Int Thrown %2.65% (#64)
IU QB Sacked %4.10% (#30)Sack %7.89% (#26)OSU QB Sacked %4.04% (#28)Sack %10.20% (#5)

Considering our two schedules, i would assume our numbers are somewhat padded. Let's face it, we've faced the lower 1/2 of the B18 so the stats favor OSU so overall, I discount our stats a bit.
But (rose coloring) we've out scored common opponents by 103, vs OSU's +59 ( Nwstn, MSU, Nebr). So there's that.

Other factors:
OSU is dinged and lost a key player, while IU is mended and now rested +IU
OSU has Day, IU has Cig. +IU
OSU has home field and preforms well at home. BUT IU had a bye week and time to plot = a wash
OSU has seen the tough challenge and tested multiple times, IU has been discounted and disrespected multiple times and has the "chip on the shoulder" = a wash
OSU has weaker kicking %, IU has a good FG % but in a small sample size. +IU

Overall, I think OSU very talented but I also think they are beatable. It's up to our Offensive Line period. Keep them off QB and get a handful of +10 yd carries.
If we can keep our offense on the field, and not have Michigan type showing, we keep this close and win a low scoring game on field goals.

IU 16
OSU 14



4th qtr.
Well.... crap. Not low scoring, nor have we been efficient since the first two drives. Muffed was punt completely deflating.

We've been good both Offense and Defense 1st, 2nd and NOT 3rd. ;-(

O line is getting killed whenever OSU decides to get aggressive.

again.... crap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: red hornet
True, but the idea behind a prediction thread is to predict what’s going to happen, not what we’d all like to see happen.

You can be a fan and not think Indiana had any shot to win today. The two aren’t mutually exclusive.
Agree fans can predict either way and it’s not a knock on them. But fans tend to be homers and in the end this is all entertainment.
 
It's a prediction thread for however you want to use it.

You do it your way the rest will do it theirs.

And some of us feel we did have shot to win today. We laid an egg. Yeah, homer glasses but also expecting Cig and Shanahan would have been a little better today on the pressure. With a bye week.
,
 
It's a prediction thread for however you want to use it.

You do it your way the rest will do it theirs.

And some of us feel we did have shot to win today. We laid an egg.
Wasn’t suggesting that people didn’t feel we had a shot. Just suggesting that being a fan doesn’t preclude you from picking the other side even though you’re not rooting for them. And anyone who suggests that you should only be a blind loyalist (or shill) is in my view out of line.
 
Wasn’t suggesting that people didn’t feel we had a shot. Just suggesting that being a fan doesn’t preclude you from picking the other side even though you’re not rooting for them. And anyone who suggests that you should only be a blind loyalist (or shill) is in my view out of line.
I know. I said we'd win. I'm not offended for looking stupid. I'm sure I was 35-40 to 60-65 on the chances but then 20 percent or more fan googles. Oh well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SRIV94
Wasn’t suggesting that people didn’t feel we had a shot. Just suggesting that being a fan doesn’t preclude you from picking the other side even though you’re not rooting for them. And anyone who suggests that you should only be a blind loyalist (or shill) is in my view out of line.
Couple of things.

First, I'm in no shape to do even simple math. You were close, so was abraxis and somebody else, but I think Geddy wins as hi numbers were close and his point differential, 21. was close to the 23 that it ended up being.

Next, what's with your post? Who gave you shit for predicting a big OSU win, and who has suggested that the only way to go here is "blind loyalty?" Anyone 1) who knows anything about college football; and 2) with an ounce of objectivity knew that this game had the potential to result in a bad loss for IU. In the first post in this thread, I said there was a wide range of possible outcomes.

I thought we had a shot today. Ohio State's vastly superior talent, and our special teams fvck ups, proved too much to overcome. I look forward to our next match-up in couple of years, hopefully in Bloomington. And no, I'm not "drinking the Kool-Aid." This program's a rocket ship. As Cignetti ups the talent level, the rest of the league - - including the Buckeyes - - will have their hands full when they play the Hoosiers. I hope Day is around for the next time we play so that IU can thoroughly kick his ass.
 
Couple of things.

First, I'm in no shape to do even simple math. You were close, so was abraxis and somebody else, but I think Geddy wins as hi numbers were close and his point differential, 21. was close to the 23 that it ended up being.

Next, what's with your post? Who gave you shit for predicting a big OSU win, and who has suggested that the only way to go here is "blind loyalty?" Anyone 1) who knows anything about college football; and 2) with an ounce of objectivity knew that this game had the potential to result in a bad loss for IU. In the first post in this thread, I said there was a wide range of possible outcomes.

I thought we had a shot today. Ohio State's vastly superior talent, and our special teams fvck ups, proved too much to overcome. I look forward to our next match-up in couple of years, hopefully in Bloomington. And no, I'm not "drinking the Kool-Aid." This program's a rocket ship. As Cignetti ups the talent level, the rest of the league - - including the Buckeyes - - will have their hands full when they play the Hoosiers.
I'm not sure how often you visit the basketball forums, but you'd be surprised how many people there make predictions strictly out of "blind loyalty" (and give those who don't do it a lot of grief for not doing so, as though it makes them feel that those who don't aren't as big a fan as they are). My comment was more general in nature, and I was not insinuating that anyone was giving me grief for the pick. My apologies if that's how it came across, because that was not my intention.

That said, I also have a belief in karma and chi, and worry when there's a huge influx of picks for Indiana against (as you correctly called them) a "vastly superior" opponent. It just didn't feel right.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT