I mean Jalen Pickett was 1st team all-B10 last year on a team that was a 10 seed in the B10 tournament.
He also averaged basically 18/7/7 and was clearly one of the best guards in the B1G... if Xavier does that, he will be 1st team and we will probably win a lot of games.
Arguing outlier examples doesn't make you point like you think it does...