ADVERTISEMENT

According to a well connected fan on another site…

Hilarious. Dominant teams don't lose to FDU...and/or get swept by IU...

The FDU game is used as a punch line...but its a very real example of why they're going to struggle to win 4 games in a row and get to a FF...let alone 6 games in a row.

Basically ALL of their perceived national "dominance" has been based on a handful of neutral site games, on or around Thanksgiving in both seasons PreConference schedule. These early season tournaments lack the intensity, feel, atmosphere...really everything of importance, that games in March in the NCAAs have.

Look at their true road games this year...

7 of them so far
5-2 record
1-2 against teams that have a prayer at NCAA...with their two losses against teams that would likely be 2nd round caliber teams.
1 other close one at Rutgers

In order to make a FF, they might have to beat 3 teams better than ANY of the teams they've played on the road thus far. In order to win a Natty, make that number 5.

True road games are essentially the most similar games teams can play to simulate NCAA tournament conditions. Purdue has been barely above average in those games the last couple years, this year included.
Hope you’re right. I’m worried they break through and it’s the classic fail, learn, and then succeed story. That would be really horrible to watch.
 
This will be the 7th of the last 9 season where painter will win over 26 games. We can all rip in them for not going far in the tourney but that is pretty darn good. He is 80-16 so far the last three seasons. My guess is he will eventually make a final four. I mean we have only made one final four in 30 years so we really go nothing to brag about.
Why not try to emulate Villanova or Kansas?

Purdue is really good. I actually enjoy watching them play. Quite obviously I'd trade what IU has done in the last few years with what they've done.

And obviously, they could break through this year. Lance Jones is a difference maker they've not had paired with Edey yet. Smith has grown quite a lot since last year. It could happen. But look at what they've looked like on the road against decent teams this year.

They're far from dominant.
 
Hope you’re right. I’m worried they break through and it’s the classic fail, learn, and then succeed story. That would be really horrible to watch.
It honestly won't bother me. Doubt it happens, but it won't bother me a ton if it does.

***edited to add... and if Purdue winning a Natty is what it takes for IU bball to pull its head out of its ass, then I'd be glad it happened. In the end, I really only care if IU is good or not.
 
This fan knows CMK’s future as well as where prospects will end up? Thats some web of connections he has.

These pronouncements seem like a reading of the tea leaves in combination of what is known today. Either way, none of it is good for IU.
 
Hilarious. Dominant teams don't lose to FDU...and/or get swept by IU...

The FDU game is used as a punch line...but its a very real example of why they're going to struggle to win 4 games in a row and get to a FF...let alone 6 games in a row.

Basically ALL of their perceived national "dominance" has been based on a handful of neutral site games, on or around Thanksgiving in both seasons PreConference schedule. These early season tournaments lack the intensity, feel, atmosphere...really everything of importance, that games in March in the NCAAs have.

Look at their true road games this year...

7 of them so far
5-2 record
1-2 against teams that have a prayer at NCAA...with their two losses against teams that would likely be 2nd round caliber teams.
1 other close one at Rutgers

In order to make a FF, they might have to beat 3 teams better than ANY of the teams they've played on the road thus far. In order to win a Natty, make that number 5.

True road games are essentially the most similar games teams can play to simulate NCAA tournament conditions. Purdue has been barely above average in those games the last couple years, this year included.
Overall body of work brother. The last 25-30 years PU been a much better program than Iu.
 
I know..I’m just getting people to think about what they are saying. Trying to compare the fire Woodson with Ohio state firing Holtmann. You can’t compare the two. Plus you don’t fire a coach after year three.
You do if you are serious about building a successful program. OSU would fire someone after year 1 in football with equivalent results. They've discussed firing Day for not beating Michigan.
 
Purdue has as good of a chance to make it to the FF as anyone else. They are the best team in the B1G, which may not be saying alot. But.....How many times has IU even been to the NCAA tournament in the past 20 years? 4 or 5? It can't be much more than that. I am an IU fan....but my daughter went to Purdue. I'll be rooting for them...as they are in the tournament and will be a high seed. IU remains irrelevant in college basketball. If you want to criticize poor track records...that one is ripe for the picking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BleedinGold
Why not try to emulate Villanova or Kansas?

Purdue is really good. I actually enjoy watching them play. Quite obviously I'd trade what IU has done in the last few years with what they've done.

And obviously, they could break through this year. Lance Jones is a difference maker they've not had paired with Edey yet. Smith has grown quite a lot since last year. It could happen. But look at what they've looked like on the road against decent teams this year.

They're far from dominant.
Yep they really are solid team. Painter should have made the final four back in 2019 honestly . He blew that game against Virginia at the end of regulation .
 
Next year is gonna be a repeat.
I have a feeling that comeback versus Ohio State saved this shitty situation from ending. Please, lose out. Be like these football first programs and care about your basketball program... wait.. Did I just say that? jfc
 
So Purdue...cool.

You young enough to endure a 40 year Final Four drought?

Good coach...

8-9 top 50 level kids, regardless of where they're from...

2-3 D1 level Indiana/Regional kids...

1-2 end of bench Indiana kids...

Or...

2-3 top 50 level kids...

8-9 D1 leve Indiana/Regional kids...

1-2 end of bench Indiana kids...


Top one gives us a legit Natty Contender ceiling, most years.

Bottom one makes us Purdue.

Better than we are now. Not what Indiana should strive for.
We have been trying to do what you are saying for 20 years now and it has led to 20 years of failure. The Purdue method isn't what I said, they rarely sniff a 5*. I am talking the Bob Knight method. The best kids from Indiana, good fits from the region, and then mix in Top 50 recruits to fill needs.

Purdue has had 2 top 50 recruits since 2017. Kaufmann-Renn and Ewing.


So no, not Purdue. Indiana. The Indiana we used to be instead of the cheap imitation Painter has to run in West Lafayette.
 
I have a feeling that comeback versus Ohio State saved this shitty situation from ending. Please, lose out. Be like these football first programs and care about your basketball program... wait.. Did I just say that? jfc
For some reason IUBB thinks these sort of wins are amazing. I don’t get it.
 
Overall body of work brother. The last 25-30 years PU been a much better program than Iu.
I've been thinking you're a Purdue troll for quite a while but today has convinced me. Go on back to your own board. You have been pumping Purdue here relentlessly for weeks, more and more blatantly. Your facade has crumbled. We had Painter-like seasons with Crean. He wasn't good enough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Willray
At least its an "imitation". "IU basketball" is a contradiction in terms at this point in time. And it will continue to be for the forseeable future. We as fans have been trained over a two decades to grin and bear it. Sure...we can come here and ventilate. But the inner circle in the IU administration and board have an entirely different set of priorities than we do. They are cleaning up financially from "basketball revenues" of every sort. It has nothing to do with results on the court. Their accountants give them the results they are really interested in.
 
I've been thinking you're a Purdue troll for quite a while but today has convinced me. Go on back to your own board. You have been pumping Purdue here relentlessly for weeks, more and more blatantly. Your facade has crumbled. We had Painter-like seasons with Crean. He wasn't good enough.
Not at all dude. Just tired of Iu renegade ball
 
You do if you are serious about building a successful program. OSU would fire someone after year 1 in football with equivalent results. They've discussed firing Day for not beating Michigan.
No they didn’t. Fans said all that. They just gave him money to hire a head coach for an offensive coordinator. They extended the basketball coach who never did better than 4th in the conference. Sounds to me they aren’t that serious.
 
Appears Woodson is going to get next season, barring an absolute collapse down the stretch. Same person said he thinks Sisley ends up at Purdue, Mullins to ND and Haralson to Duke. He said the families of these kids like IU, but just not a fan of the style of play.

Man, if you can’t recruit your own state…..
If he were to strike out, if retained, they should fire him for that alone.
 
No they didn’t. Fans said all that. They just gave him money to hire a head coach for an offensive coordinator. They extended the basketball coach who never did better than 4th in the conference. Sounds to me they aren’t that serious.
He is 56-8 in his career and the fan base is putting heat on admin. Osu will do everything they can to win. Next year is huge for Day
 
  • Like
Reactions: demunn
Our backcourt can't keep up. Not sure why everyone has to go straight to fire Woody because injuries have been a big factor. We are not good this year but changing coaches now feels a bit extreme. Same-same next year and I'll drive the dang buss. Too early to call for a change. Just one guy's opinion. Go Hoosiers!
Phuck injuries. I get it hasn’t been ideal, but when you don’t recruit depth, injuries mean more. On the coaches, period
 
We have been trying to do what you are saying for 20 years now and it has led to 20 years of failure. The Purdue method isn't what I said, they rarely sniff a 5*. I am talking the Bob Knight method. The best kids from Indiana, good fits from the region, and then mix in Top 50 recruits to fill needs.

Purdue has had 2 top 50 recruits since 2017. Kaufmann-Renn and Ewing.


So no, not Purdue. Indiana. The Indiana we used to be instead of the cheap imitation Painter has to run in West Lafayette.

This is the way. You are absolutely right that you guys could have done the Purdue method but at a higher level.

You had the prestige, the resources, the brand cache, etc.

The new Indiana has been trying the watered down Kentucky way for 20 years now.

IU hasn't seen a Final Four in 23 years and only 1 in the last 30. One in which IU went through like three double digits seeds to get to. That team was also made up of the culture of RMK.

This idea that Indiana's new 5 star strategy is even remotely a good idea is fools gold. It can hardly make the tournament on any sort of consistent basis.

If Purdue wins a natty this year it's going to be one more nail in the coffin for the old IU brand in this state.

Time to right the ship is dwindling. That "40 year" clock is fast approaching for the Hoosiers.
 
He is 56-8 in his career and the fan base is putting heat on admin. Osu will do everything they can to win. Next year is huge for Day
How much you want to bet he’s there in 3 years? Football isn’t basketball either. They let Holtmann run around for 7 years. Ohio state football is a different animal than Ohio state basketball.
 
This is the way. You are absolutely right that you guys could have done the Purdue method but at a higher level.

You had the prestige, the resources, the brand cache, etc.

The new Indiana has been trying the watered down Kentucky way for 20 years now.

IU hasn't seen a Final Four in 23 years and only 1 in the last 30. One in which IU went through like three double digits seeds to get to. That team was also made up of the culture of RMK.

This idea that Indiana's new 5 star strategy is even remotely a good idea is fools gold. It can hardly make the tournament on any sort of consistent basis.

If Purdue wins a natty this year it's going to be one more nail in the coffin for the old IU brand in this state.

Time to right the ship is dwindling. That "40 year" clock is fast approaching for the Hoosiers.
We’ve. Had. Horrible. Coaching.

Villanova and Kansas are the way, for IU. With a good coach.

Sampson would have won multiple nattys by now at IU, and he wouldn’t have focused on Indiana kids.

Not saying I want a Sampson-like program. But Id take a Jay Wright-like program, and that is more than realistic.

IU just needs the right coach.
 
Holtmann did sign an extension in '22. Their new AD - Ross Bjork from Texas A&M - probably didn't want that hanging over his head and probably wants to make a splash with a big basketball hire.

As an aside, with all the talent and new coaches they brought in on the football side, Ryan Day probably needs to win the Big Ten outright and be at least in the final four of the new playoff to keep his job, as crazy as that sounds.
It is true that OSU football has very high standards. Tom Allen would have been a coach there for 5 minutes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbafficionado
This is the way. You are absolutely right that you guys could have done the Purdue method but at a higher level.

You had the prestige, the resources, the brand cache, etc.

The new Indiana has been trying the watered down Kentucky way for 20 years now.

IU hasn't seen a Final Four in 23 years and only 1 in the last 30. One in which IU went through like three double digits seeds to get to. That team was also made up of the culture of RMK.

This idea that Indiana's new 5 star strategy is even remotely a good idea is fools gold. It can hardly make the tournament on any sort of consistent basis.

If Purdue wins a natty this year it's going to be one more nail in the coffin for the old IU brand in this state.

Time to right the ship is dwindling. That "40 year" clock is fast approaching for the Hoosiers.
Talk about counting chickens. When pU loses in the tournament will you eat crow?
 
How much you want to bet he’s there in 3 years? Football isn’t basketball either. They let Holtmann run around for 7 years. Ohio state football is a different animal than Ohio state basketball.
I’m not betting on it but they are spending a crap ton this off season. If he doesn’t get it done, I could see them moving on or he taking another job.
 
I’m not betting on it but they are spending a crap ton this off season. If he doesn’t get it done, I could see them moving on or he taking another job.
They will march through the B1G next year. They will be a top 2 in the playoff.
 
The OP presents a speculative view of the future regarding current recruits and the program as it exists today in-game on the floor (and by extension—off of it).

I don’t disagree with any of it because that too would involve a fair deal of speculation on my part. Not my thing.
Evidence based individual by and large.

What I do not think is in the least way speculative is that the culture of this program is and has been broken.

Wins would help for sure.
All the 5 stars are a plus. Certainly don’t hurt. Thank God for a good airport look to this squad.
But culture is what engenders enduring success.

Culture isn’t coming from 17 year old recruits.
Culture certainly isn’t coming from this ass-chapped fan base and what is said daily about admin, coaching and players.

No answers here. Also no speculation.

Facts are facts.

No one logical wants this garbage for their family especially with greener grass all over the country.

Beard, Day, Stevens whoever will look hard at not what the sycophants here see but what the rest of the college world sees. Likely already have.
The “I’ll fix it guy” (for a truckload) may be out there. I think we might have one now. Anyone want another one?

Every parent and recruit sees all this too.

Regardless of our abundantly stated ability to out-bid/buy all of them.

Can’t buy culture.
 
Why the hell are people concerned with getting Indiana players. News flash, they normally suck!!!

We got lander and Romeo with Archie, worked out real well.

Just get good players, who cares where the hell they are from.

I forget if Furst and Trey Kaughman were from Indiana, they suck too!
Furst was a kid IU wanted. He has not developed under painter.
 
We’ve. Had. Horrible. Coaching.

Villanova and Kansas are the way, for IU. With a good coach.

Sampson would have won multiple nattys by now at IU, and he wouldn’t have focused on Indiana kids.

Not saying I want a Sampson-like program. But Id take a Jay Wright-like program, and that is more than realistic.

IU just needs the right coach.
Sampson would have been caught if IU hadn't turned him in because he had already been caught at OU. And then it would have been a 5 year post season ban and scholarship restrictions for 4-6 years because IU hired a known cheater, and then covered up for him. The penalty would have been as high as the NCAA could go short of the death penalty..
 
Sampson would have been caught if IU hadn't turned him in because he had already been caught at OU. And then it would have been a 5 year post season ban and scholarship restrictions for 4-6 years because IU hired a known cheater, and then covered up for him. The penalty would have been as high as the NCAA could go short of the death penalty..
Actually a I think it was a Purdue tied lawyer(watchdog)got him I believe. Senderhoff was doing all kinds of stuff too. IU just took control and self imposed, fired etc…this was when the ncaa wasn’t fighting lawsuits. That’s how KU and UNC won. They saw how vulnerable they had become. Time and timing is not a friend to IU. Maybe coach sig changes the football future.
 
You don’t think IU can use what PU has done and then sprinkle in your JHS?
You have to have a core and a culture. We have chased the Vonlehs, Romeo’s, MBAkwo, types and won absolutely nothing. Recruit a core!! I would love to have guys like Gillis, Smith and a Loyer on our roster.
I think that’s kind of what he’s saying.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bsmitty08
I agree, if the fumble again like this year. It will get restless in Columbus. They honestly should win it next talent wise.
This is setting up for Ohio state and Georgia. If Day wins it or makes it to the final game they will back him 100%. Who else are they going to hire?
 
Yes a mix but you can’t tell me PU isn’t doing something right. They have been the most dominant team in the country for two years now. I’d bet they make a final 4 this year if not win it all. I haven’t seen anyone wow me this year
What Painter has done is outlast Beilein, Matta, Ryan, and Izzo (better coaches) and reaped the benefits of IU's coaching hire failures. If Matt was going to do something on the national stage, he would have done it 15 years ago. If it walks like Gene, talks like Gene, looks like Gene, etc.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT