The reality of NIL...

[BoilerN]

is there going to be a cap? is everyone going to adhere to it? are all qbs paid the same? are linemen going to make as much? how are smaller budget schools going to compete. there's a great deal to work out.

The big ten is 20.5 mil I think. A few aren’t going to be 100% though I don’t think. SEC might be around 21 mil. Everyone else less. I think that’s what i saw?

From there, it’s up to the school. My biggest question is title nine. But if it goes strictly by profit, then how does the breakdown at Purdue compare to a place like Nebraska? Because Nebraska makes way more in volleyball than Purdue. It will be interesting. We will get answers in April.

 

[BoilerN]

Collectives aren’t going anywhere. It’s a desperate plea by the NCAA to try and curtail the mess they’ve created but they’ve lost every landmark court case since the Supreme Court ruled their “amateur” model violated anti-trust laws for nearly a century.

I don’t think they are going anywhere. But they aren’t going to be as effective as currently. Will be interesting to see. No one knows what is going to happen.

 

[Hoosiers Rising]

Collectives aren’t going anywhere. It’s a desperate plea by the NCAA to try and curtail the mess they’ve created but they’ve lost every landmark court case since the Supreme Court ruled their “amateur” model violated anti-trust laws for nearly a century.

Did they cause the mess or just allow it to spiral out of control? I mean they had control and someone took it away. Maybe they said OK let’s see how you handle this.

 

[Victorbmyboy]

We probably need to see at a minimum…multi-year contracts or sit out a year after transferring.

No way the sit a year rule comes back. Multi-year is already happening. Michigan signed a QB for multi year. Among others.

 

[Spartans9312]

No way the sit a year rule comes back. Multi-year is already happening. Michigan signed a QB for multi year. Among others.

The contract is with the school?

 

[Victorbmyboy]

The contract is with the school?

No but..yes. 10.5 million for 4 years.

 

[BoilerN]

No but..yes. 10.5 million for 4 years.

And if he leaves early? Or Michigan wants out early?

 

[Spartans9312]

No but..yes. 10.5 million for 4 years.

Can’t transfer, guaranteed pay, must stay 4 years?

 

[Victorbmyboy]

And if he leaves early? Or Michigan wants out early?

If..but…but. It’s 10.5 million if he stays.

 

[Victorbmyboy]

Can’t transfer, guaranteed pay, must stay 4 years?

To get the 10.5 million yes.

 

[Spartans9312]

To get the 10.5 million yes.

So it’s a 1 year deal….nothing binding

 

[BoilerN]

So it’s a 1 year deal….nothing binding

Sounds that way. Idk. He didn’t really answer me either. I’m sure there is a way to get out of it if he sucks.

 

[IndyResident16]

Did they cause the mess or just allow it to spiral out of control? I mean they had control and someone took it away. Maybe they said OK let’s see how you handle this.

Well both. They had 20 some years to incorporate some kind of fair compensation/revenue sharing model and doubled down.

 

[Hoosiers Rising]

Well both. They had 20 some years to incorporate some kind of fair compensation/revenue sharing model and doubled down.

I agree that what should have been done and what should be done now. Equal for every player. Cats out of the bag now, though, kittens everywhere.

 

[Mas-sa-suta]

The issue is that it would be very difficult to control and prevent abuse. Knowing something is happening and proving it are sometimes very different animals.

Yep..

See Bucknuts U.

 

[Big Red Crimson Buffalo]

I’m in full favor of a “12th man” NIL payout system for the fans that attend games. Fans play a role with effort, noise and creating the environment to earn wins. You physically show up to a game and stay and cheer till the end? You receive cash payouts on your way out of the stadium. Our time is now!

 

[Al Bino]

This has nothing to do with Purdue. Don’t bring them up and derail the thread.

Why are you here on your rivals board?
You seem to take a contrary view of what is discussed and are generally argumentative.

I show up at my ex's Christmas celebration and I bet no one would throw me out but why would I be there and am I there to just cause problems and I wouldn't be wanted there.

Kind of like you being here.

 

[BoilerN]

Why are you here on your rivals board?
You seem to take a contrary view of what is discussed and are generally argumentative.

I show up at my ex's Christmas celebration and I bet no one would throw me out but why would I be there and am I there to just cause problems and I wouldn't be wanted there.

Kind of like you being here.

Not argumentative. I never feel like I’m arguing. But again. This thread has nothing to do with Purdue. So why bring them up? Why can’t we just talk about NIL and CB negotiations?

With that being said, here is a good article that found me that aligns with what I kind of believe is happening. https://www.cbssports.com/watch/col...transfer-wr-duce-robinson?ftag=CBS-16-10adi8e

 

[Hoosier Clarion]

Not argumentative. I never feel like I’m arguing. But again. This thread has nothing to do with Purdue. So why bring them up? Why can’t we just talk about NIL and CB negotiations?

With that being said, here is a good article that found me that aligns with what I kind of believe is happening. https://www.cbssports.com/watch/col...transfer-wr-duce-robinson?ftag=CBS-16-10adi8e

The reason why is we don't like your BS. You better get to selling that manure. The west bank of the river is piling high.

 

[82hoosier]

Looking at rivals list of top 250 high school recruits: top 10 Indiana has signed ZERO. The good news is a lot of them will eventually be in the portal.

 

[Mas-sa-suta]

Looking at rivals list of top 250 high school recruits: top 10 Indiana has signed ZERO. The good news is a lot of them will eventually be in the portal.

The paradigm is changing rapidly for sure. It's the Wild West in the 21st Century. It will take a couple of seasons to demonstrate that the 'New' IU is the real deal.

 

[76-1]

Looking at rivals list of top 250 high school recruits: top 10 Indiana has signed ZERO. The good news is a lot of them will eventually be in the portal.

That's because all of these true freshman (aside from our most recent QB [Bell] ) were recruited prior to this season and all had committed (other than the QB) prior to it...

The real payoff from this past season should be seen in the "25" & "26" classes along with doors that it opened 3 to 5 years in the future....

 

[Army88]

Can’t transfer, guaranteed pay, must stay 4 years?

Did any form of this transfer concept/rule pass? (Affects NIL, but an independent issue that needs to be altered-IMO)
“First transfer is immediate eligibility, second is wait a year. Graduates gain immediate and some hardship exceptions gain immediate eligibility “.

 

[Spartans9312]

Did any form of this transfer concept/rule pass? (Affects NIL, but an independent issue that needs to be altered-IMO)
“First transfer is immediate eligibility, second is wait a year. Graduates gain immediate and some hardship exceptions gain immediate eligibility “.

I do not have a clue…I thought Vic was stating that the Michigan QB signed a 4 year deal….hence my questions

 

[Big Red Crimson Buffalo]

Did any form of this transfer concept/rule pass? (Affects NIL, but an independent issue that needs to be altered-IMO)
“First transfer is immediate eligibility, second is wait a year. Graduates gain immediate and some hardship exceptions gain immediate eligibility “.

As of May 30, 2024, student-athletes can transfer an unlimited number of times without penalty and be immediately eligible.

 

[OpenWheels]

The NCAA has no balls or foresight.

Of course, it's whatever the most powerful sports schools want. So they must think a free for all is beneficial.
,

 

[red hornet]

Plus, the NCAA continued to lose in court.