Carroll County men don't wear crocs. You should know that.
I have 1 pair of black Sketchers that can double as dress shoes under the right circumstances. I wear them to the gym, too, and they're fine on the treadmill.
I have a pair of regular black shoes that I use for funerals, weddings, and church (when I go).
I do have a pair of hiking shoes that I bought before going to Glacier National Park and Banff last year. I never wear them.
I grew up in an environment where we put cardboard in our shoes to make up for the hole in the soles. I wear shoes until the soles come loose. Kind of like jeans, only I don't have to cover the holes with patches anymore - I can afford new ones now.