ADVERTISEMENT

Can someone explain this JP Morgan thing to me?

What, are they hoarding gold or something? @JamieDimonsBalls

No, they are just the broker for derivatives and hedges. I think the massive amount of speculation in gold, among other commodities, is the biggest reason for such a high physical delivery.

 
No, they are just the broker for derivatives and hedges. I think the massive amount of speculation in gold, among other commodities, is the biggest reason for such a high physical delivery.

I appreciate your effort, but you'll forgive me I hope if it still sounds like alchemy. I have no idea what any of this means.
 
No, they are just the broker for derivatives and hedges. I think the massive amount of speculation in gold, among other commodities, is the biggest reason for such a high physical delivery.

I haven't wrapped my head around this: if it's an arbitrage situation, how would that lead to the need for physical delivery? I can’t think of a scenerio where you couldn't just capture the profit without having to send/receive delivery.

Just for reference, there have been 3 yrs in my 25 yr career that I made more money trading commodities than I did farming them. One of those years was definitely nothing to brag about, but I do know a little bit about it.

We've seen oil go negative, because the guys in the wrong position didn't have a place to store it. Likewise, many farmers complain about the US importing corn and beans, but the reason for the import is that because of market and currency differences it is cheaper to get the commodities shipped from SA to close positions than it is from just down the road.

A major difference here is the nature of the commodity. You can’t eat it or burn it. It could sit over there, or sit over here. Nonetheless, very interesting.

 
Last edited:
I haven't wrapped my head around this: if it's an arbitrage situation, how would that lead to the need for physical delivery? I can’t think of a scenerio where you couldn't just capture the profit without having to send/receive delivery.

Just for reference, there have been 3 yrs in my 25 yr career that I made more money trading commodities than I did farming them. One of those years was definitely nothing to brag about, but I do know a little bit about it.

We've seen oil go negative, because the guys in the wrong position didn't have a place to store it. Likewise, many farmers complain about the US importing corn and beans, but the reason for the import is that because of market and currency differences it is cheaper to get the commodities shipped from SA to close positions than it is from just down the road.

A major difference here is the nature of the commodity. You can’t eat it or burn it. It could sit over there, or sit over here. Nonetheless, very interesting.


I don’t know who is on the other (or both sides) of the trade, but perhaps the cash settlement option is not favorable? I’m not a derivatives or commodity guy.

I just know most of JPM’s business is brokering vs investing directly, so much of this I would assume is on behalf of clients.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Digressions
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT