Would he have his job if his dad wasn’t the head coach? Would he be a P5 OC anywhere else? i
1) Maybe.
2) Not now, but back when he was hired, probably yes. He's a very good tight ends coach. A very good offensive line coach. And probably a very good OC, but without the talent as evidenced by Iowa's very poor last season, and this season. 8 wins might be better than a lot of schools, but it's pretty disappointing up here where we have special teams and defenses that compete with almost any team in America, but the offense lacks. More accurately, the execution lacks, the offensive strategy does not lack. That's not too fine of a line without crawling into the weeds.
Don't misunderstand, Iowa's offensive strategy is a winning strategy. But even Iowa fans want to change this, which just shows how few college football fans understand football.
You would have to really dial down into Iowa's last season, and this season to understand. Injuries, attrition, several player going early to the NFL, which for a school like Iowa is a bigger deal than some other schools. You look at some of this, and then look at what they accomplished and that's a very simple way to judge coaching. Iowa's season was over last season, several losses in a row, and the coaching staff resurrected it, with a hodge podge team that ended up beating a mid level SEC school. That's coaching, and probably a better coaching job than when Iowa went 12-0. Few take the time to recognize or understand this.
I've attended every Iowa game at Indiana since KF has been the HC. I just listen to what people say in the stadium, and it's revealing. It's not worth arguing with them. I've been to closed practices at several B1G schools, including Indiana. You find very quickly you're best off letting fans think what they think.
Bill Belichick doesn't hire bad coaches. Many colleges do however. Indiana didn't hire a bad coach, there are some systemic issues that are a larger challenge.