Updated List. I eliminated name that I don't think are realistic due to retention or salary limitations. Got a new #1 on the list based on more research. Focused on smaller school OC's with coordinator experienced that are likely "hirable".
Eliminated Names: Seth Litrell, Phillip Montgomery, Justin Fuentes, Matt Luke, Sterlin Gilbert, Dan Mullen. If any of these guys got fired or are interested you'd' probably take one of them.
Sterlin Gilbert - Recently fired Syracuse OC. Improved Syracuse's offense dramatically in one season. Not sure if there is an uknown story here, but productivity has never been an issue with Gilbert. A bit of a coaching nomad, but he's been successful at every stop. Never had an offense that did not produce. Runs a spread with very successful rushing attacks.
2021- Syracuse - 25 pts a game (previous year they scored 17)
2018 South Florida - 29 pts, 438 yards per game of offense
2017 South Florida - 38 pts/game, 513 yards per game
2016 Texas - 32pts/game, 492 ypg, 5.9 yards per play
1a. Tim Cramsey - Offensive Coordinator at Marshall coming off excellent year. Has been retained across two coaches at Marshall which is unusual. He's been a productive and sometimes record breaking offensive coordinator at five different schools. Marshall's offense gets better with every year he is there. This year it averaged 35 pts a game with a balanced run pass attack. Has had two years where his teams scored over 40 points a game at prior stops. Has a balanced run and pass offense. He's also a quarterbacks coach. Unlike other targets this one is affordable and is probably the most attainable under the radar type hire the Hoosiers could make.
2021 - 35pts/g, 480 yards per game - Marshall
2020- 28pts/game, 391 yards per game, 5.9 yards/play Marshall
2019 - 26pts/game, 393 yards per game, 5.8 yards/play Marshall
2018 - 29pts/game, 388 yards per game, 5.6 yards/play Marshall
2017 - 44pts/game. 538 yards per game, 7 yards/play Sam Houston State
2016 - 25pts/game 382 yards per game, Nevada
1b. Doug Meachem - TCU - Will probably be let go at TCU. Long time coordinator with a lot of record breaking offenses. One down strike is one year at Kansas as OC did not go well. That would be a comparable to IU. Probably lands a bigger job, but he's the best career OC available. He also is a former lineman and has coached every position on the offense.
2021 - TCU 29pts/game, 440 yards per game, 6.7 yards per play TCU
2016 - TCU 31 pts/game, 468 yards per game
2015 - TCU 42pts/game, 560 yards a game TCU
2014 - TCU 46 pts a game, 533 yards a game TCU
1c. Mike Bloomgren - Head Coach at Rice. The architect of Stanford's highly regarded power rushing offenses from 2013 to 2017. He's an offensive line coach by trade which would go a long way toward fixing Indiana's main problem. Would probably be a "Sliver Bullet" hire in terms of bringing the physical hard nose rushing attack that fits Allen's personality. Offense improved dramatically in his three year tenure as offensive coordinator averaging 38 points a game featuring a dominant rushing attack that averaged almost 300 yards a game. Coached a dozen linemen who went on to play in the NFL. He's an elite offensive line coach in addition to being a potential offensive coordinator. His down side is that his Rice offenses have been terrible and have not been able to run the ball.
2. Zack Kittley - Western Kentucky OC - has broken records with Western Kentucky's offense after doing the same as a head coach of Houston Baptist. Not much run game to speak of but his offense scored 41 points a game this year and was third in yards per play. He would be a short term answer as he's a likely head coach candidate. IU would have to be willing to go with an air raid spread which has not delivered as many wins as run game spreads.
2021 43 pts a game, 528 yards per game, 7.2 yards per play - Western Kentucky
2019 - 428 yards per game - Houston Baptist
3. Frank Ponce - App State Offensive Coordinator - First year offensive coordinator did a great job at App State. Highly regarded QB coach. Offense averaged 450 yards and 36 pts a game.
2021 - 37 pts/game 450 yards a game, 6/2 yards per play - Appalachian State
4. Willy Korn - OC at Coastal Carolina - Having an awful lot of success at Coastal Carolina. Question is whether the head coach who is heavily involved with the offense is the real genius here. Top OC's under offensive minded coaches tend to do well, but it's never a sure thing when the head coach is also heavily involved in the offense.
2021 - 40 pts game, 490 yards a game, 7.6 yards per play - Coastal Carolina
2020 37 pts game, 450 yards, 6.7 yards per play - Coastal Carolina
5. Barry Lunney Jr. Lunney has had two very strong years at OC at UTSA. Has the strangest resume in that he was a college offensive coordinator then became a high school offensive coordinator for eight years, then a college position coach then a college OC. He is highly regarded and was Arkansas's head coach for two games. Offense averaged 6 yards a play, 440 a game with 38 pts a game.
2021 - 38 pts per game, 440 yards per game, 6.1 yard per play UTSA
2020 - 28 pts per game, 415, 5.8 yards per play UTSA
6. Eric Eidsness - Northern Illinois OC. This guy is a an up and comer who has done a good job at Northern Illinois. His offense has been very balanced. Was OC for six years at South Dakota State and oversaw record breaking offenses during this period. Has a very balanced spread attack. He coaches under a coach who was never an OC so it looks like Eidsness truly coordinates this offense unlike other candidates who are "right hand man" type coaches.
2021 - 31pts per game, 420 yards per game, 6.1 yards per play Northern Illinois
2020 - 24 pts per game, 367 yards per game, 5 yards per play Northern Illinois
2019 - 22 pts per game, 322 yards per game Northern Illinois
2018 - 42 pts a game South Dakota State
7. Ryan Grubb OC Fresno State - If you can't get Kalen Deboer maybe you get his protege. Grubb would be a strong candidate for three reasons. The first is that he's a long time line coach and if you hired the wrong line coach he's going to know how to step in and fix that. His teams allowed less than a sack a game for the past three seasons. He's also now the QB coach so he's got a very unusual background. And of course he coaches with Deboer so our players will know both his offense and his terminology. He coached two really good offensive coaches. Only question is whether he's a right hand man or the leader of the offense. Deboer is a front runner at Washington which probably rules Grubb out.
8. Anthony Tucker - Utah State OC. Former OC for Josh Heupel at UCF who has vastly improved Utah State's offense in his first year on the job. Pass heavy offense. Offense went from 15pts a game in the year before he got there to 32 a game this year. Had very balanced offenses at UCF. An ex running backs coach who coordinated the passing game at UCF.
10. Mike Thiessen OC Air Force. An unconventional pick for a school that might need an unconventional approach. Been an OC for a long time. Offenses are run heavy option hybrid that eat up clock and protect the defense. Has lead to an awful lot of wins.
11. Sam Gregg - Liberty Offensive Line Coach - Former Offensive Coordinator at West Georgia for six years. Coached under a great offensive mind at Liberty and has a decade of former OC experience. Might be a strong candidate because of his background as both a coordinator and a line coach. Might kill two birds with one stone or hedge against another bad line coach hire.
12. Robert Weiner - OC at Toledo who was Tom Allen Jr's former high school coach. Likely a relationship here. Toledo was respectable offensively this year, but not outstanding. Toledo's coach has a reputation as an excellent offensive mind. Weiner won four state championships as a high school coach. Allen could do much worse. Toledo's offense was second in the MAC in scoring at 33 pts a game.
2021 - 34 pts/game, 430 yards per game, 6.1 yards per play.
2020 - 35 pts/game, 494 yards per game, 6.4 yards per play
13. Justin Frye - UCLA Offensive Coordinator Former IU player. Unlikely to leave an OC job at UCLA. Ranked lower because he's an unlikely candidate.
14. Brian Hartline - Ohio State Receivers Coach - Elite Elite recruiter. Is coaching under one of the best offensive minds in the country. Downside is no offensive coordinator experience. Would certainly fix our receivers though. He's viewed as a future coaching star and should at least be interviewed.