I think people forget that it was rationalized by most at the time as a welcomed hire. Yes, he got caught at Oklahoma in a little bit of shadiness, but everyone assumed that after a guy is embarrassed once, he wouldn’t dare jeopardize a dream job like IU by doing something stupid twice. Most coaches would have kept their noses clean and let the chips fall as they may. Maybe he abused his cell phone privileges due to the perceived pressure to succeed.
Still, if IU hadn’t self reported, oh, what might have been instead. A big fat book could easily be filled on the rise and demise of IU basketball. Unfortunately, the story is still being written with no immediate end in sight.
Cell phones were a relatively new recruiting tool at the time and I don’t think phone call histories were appreciated like they are today in solving crimes. I can’t believe some other coaches weren’t doing the same thing. It would have been easy for other athletic directors to say, “Hey, maybe we should go back and look at some of our coach’s phone logs just to make sure we’re clean”. No other school ever reported any cell phone infractions, which is surprising to me. I guess other schools weren’t stupid enough to blow the whistle on their own coach’s, after all, look what it did to Indiana.