ADVERTISEMENT

Trump's brown-shirted menace

I'm recalling Tea Party members interrupting and shouting down, and eventually causing meetings about Health Care to cancel. Anyone else recall that? Those people called themselves Patriots. I bet these same people are calling these kids thugs.

They aren't kids. They are professional agitators. Moveon has been funding and organizing them.


Trump is a POS. And so are the agitators. The far left of this country is just as disturbing as Trump. All losers. All fascists that want to shout down/shut up/intimidate opposition.

They have a lot more in common than they know. Ignorance.

This country is truly fucjed.
 
Last edited:
They aren't kids. They are professional agitators. Moveon has been funding and organizing them.


Trump is a POS. And so are the agitators. The far left of this country is just as disturbing as Trump. All losers. All fascists that want to shout down/shut up/intimidate opposition.

They have a lot more in common than they know. Ignorance.

This country is truly fucjed.
Prove it. The only times I've seen this claim anywhere but this forum have been directly from the mouths of Trump or Rubio. The only legitimate journalism I found that examined the protesters themselves (which I linked on page 1 of this thread) made it clear it was very well organized - but also organic and grass roots.

I'm not saying the evidence doesn't exist, but step up to the plate and supply it, please.
 
Sanders Sends Vegan Thugs to Attack Peace-Loving Nazis

You know I was talking with a pretty staunch republican last week and related why he didn't think Bernie was a good politician. He thought this due to him not becoming a millionaire while in office nor getting a billionaire back.

Talk about your warped since of purpose... another reason we need a reset and that will be by electing a non status quo candidate.

Oh yeah, and get rid of Citizen's United.
 
Prove it. The only times I've seen this claim anywhere but this forum have been directly from the mouths of Trump or Rubio. The only legitimate journalism I found that examined the protesters themselves (which I linked on page 1 of this thread) made it clear it was very well organized - but also organic and grass roots.

I'm not saying the evidence doesn't exist, but step up to the plate and supply it, please.

Hard to pin down exactly. But do you really believe these are spontaneous protesters?

http://www.youngcons.com/moveon-org-takes-credit-for-assault-on-trumps-rally-tonight/
 
That's better, but it looks a lot more like giving approval than taking credit. I'm more interested in the wild claims that these "aren't protesters, they're professional agitators."

Do you think it appropriate for protestors to stotm stages at Trump speeches? And have to be physically removed...like the recent guy that was at the podium?

We need people on your side to call this out....or we are going down a terrible rabbit hole.

I'm honestly very concerned for the country. And I don't think we want to see the pure visceral instincts of our populations come out in full

We're all animals, at the end of the day.
 
Do you think it appropriate for protestors to stotm stages at Trump speeches? And have to be physically removed...like the recent guy that was at the podium?

We need people on your side to call this out....or we are going down a terrible rabbit hole.

I'm honestly very concerned for the country. And I don't think we want to see the pure visceral instincts of our populations come out in full

We're all animals, at the end of the day.
Straw man.
 
Maybe you were, but now you've pivoted into attacking me for things I never said. Get back to the discussion at hand, and I'll gladly continue.

Are you phucking drunk? What did I attack you about?

You were pissed that I used agitators in my earlier comment. That's about the most vile thing I've said here.

We need better behavior from both sides. This country is gonna be phucked if we let Donald win with making us into animals that retreat to their corners.
 
Are you phucking drunk? What did I attack you about?

You were pissed that I used agitators in my earlier comment. That's about the most vile thing I've said here.
You turned our discussion from your accusation that these protesters are actually paid shills to an accusation that I "have no concern" over the anger we are seeing. Straw man. By definition.
 
They aren't kids. They are professional agitators. Moveon has been funding and organizing them.


Trump is a POS. And so are the agitators. The far left of this country is just as disturbing as Trump. All losers. All fascists that want to shout down/shut up/intimidate opposition.

They have a lot more in common than they know. Ignorance.

This country is truly fucjed.
Well I have a former student at UIC that went with hundreds of students. Pretty sure they aren't professional agitators and you won't see them at any other venues. Plain old college students. And she was political as a second grader...
 
Last edited:
You turned our discussion from your accusation that these protesters are actually paid shills to an accusation that I "have no concern" over the anger we are seeing. Straw man. By definition.

Ok. See above my comment. Letting this turn into a shit storm about personality disputes is very bad.

I believe people on both sides of the aisle need to repudiate bad behavior for it to be stomped out.

Trump is an ABOMINATION.

I find him repulsive. I'll shout that all year long, as a life long GOP member. He sucks not just for the GOP, but for the entire country, as he brings out the animalistic instinct that is the ugliest of the human race.


I still don't believe the storming his stages/rally is appropriate. And all it will do is galvanize his support.
 
Ok. See above my comment. Letting this turn into a shit storm about personality disputes is very bad.

I believe people on both sides of the aisle need to repudiate bad behavior for it to be stomped out.

Trump is an ABOMINATION.

I find him repulsive. I'll shout that all year long, as a life long GOP member. He sucks not just for the GOP, but for the entire country, as he brings out the animalistic instinct that is the ugliest of the human race.
I agree with all your comments about Trump, but you accused the protesters of being "professional agitators." You specifically accused moveon.org of paying for them to disrupt rallies. I took issue with that accusation, and you turned this discussion into something else entirely to avoid the fact that you couldn't prove your charge. I never went anywhere else with this, and that's why everything else you directed at me was a straw man.
 
Since you mentioned the old guy - I haven't said here or anywhere who I am voting for primary (which may matter) nor general. I am considering (gulp) asking for the Democrat Primary ballot to vote for Bernie as an effort to defeat Clinton. Considering. So, thus far, I am not a Trump supporter. I am watching the left rant and rave on this board. They have no idea what to do about their socialist nor their criminal candidate. Its interesting watching
You sure surprise me. I was sure you would be a Trump supporter. ;)
 
I agree with all your comments about Trump, but you accused the protesters of being "professional agitators." You specifically accused moveon.org of paying for them to disrupt rallies. I took issue with that accusation, and you turned this discussion into something else entirely to avoid the fact that you couldn't prove your charge. I never went anywhere else with this, and that's why everything else you directed at me was a straw man.

I had an opinion that the Trump protestors were an organized group. Is that really outlandish? Or unusual? Would that really be shocking?

I spent plenty of time trying to start a normal conversation, but you are so bent, it's worthless.
 
I had an opinion that the Trump protestors were an organized group. Is that really outlandish? Or unusual? Would that really be shocking?

I spent plenty of time trying to start a normal conversation, but you are so bent, it's worthless.
No, you didn't. You made a plain accusation that they were "professionals" funded by moveon.org. Either prove your accusation or admit you cannot. Every other line of discussion right now is a distraction. Can you prove your claim or can't you?
 
They aren't kids. They are professional agitators. Moveon has been funding and organizing them.


Trump is a POS. And so are the agitators. The far left of this country is just as disturbing as Trump. All losers. All fascists that want to shout down/shut up/intimidate opposition.

They have a lot more in common than they know. Ignorance.

This country is truly fucjed.

It wouldn't surprise me in the least if we found out it was some other republican groups organizing the protesters at Trump rallies. The republican establishment has made it clear they don't want Trump.
 
No, you didn't. You made a plain accusation that they were "professionals" funded by moveon.org. Either prove your accusation or admit you cannot. Every other line of discussion right now is a distraction. Can you prove your claim or can't you?

http://m.washingtontimes.com/news/2016/mar/13/moveonorg-raising-funds-from-trump-protests-warns-/

Here is now the 3rd link I have provided.

"to the support we provided students in Chicago last night by printing signs and a banner and recruiting MoveOn.org members to join their peaceful protest. We need to double-down in the face of direct attacks on our community,” the email read.

And it pledged to continue its work.


Trump’s racist, bigoted, misogynistic, xenophobic, and violent behavior — and show the world that America rejects Trump’s hate,” the email read. “And to keep it going, we’re counting on you to donate whatever you can to cover the costs of everything involved — the organizers, signs, online recruitment ads, training, and more.”



Is that enough?
 
No, you didn't. You made a plain accusation that they were "professionals" funded by moveon.org. Either prove your accusation or admit you cannot. Every other line of discussion right now is a distraction. Can you prove your claim or can't you?


How about directly from their site? That enough?

"We helped student leaders by printing signs and recruiting MoveOn members to attend the student-led protest."

http://front.moveon.org/trump-chicago-dishonest/#.Vuf-Y0QpDqA
 
You sure surprise me. I was sure you would be a Trump supporter. ;)
There you go thinkin' again.

What are my choices? Among all of them, I haven't chosen. I'm not an anybody supporter yet. Thee is some horrible crap being dealt by the let just now, so probably I can't vote for the Socialist nor the Felon nor Rubio who does not know when the game is overbut I am undecided and even considering Sanders to stop the criminal if the vote matters by May 3.
 
How about directly from their site? That enough?

"We helped student leaders by printing signs and recruiting MoveOn members to attend the student-led protest."

http://front.moveon.org/trump-chicago-dishonest/#.Vuf-Y0QpDqA
How about the quotes in articles from the Chicago PD who say the violence was all Sanders/Clinton supporters, organized and much worse than reported including selectively breaking the windows out of cars with Trump bumper stickers.
 
No, you didn't. You made a plain accusation that they were "professionals" funded by moveon.org. Either prove your accusation or admit you cannot. Every other line of discussion right now is a distraction. Can you prove your claim or can't you?

More from some Bernie affiliated agitators.

“We wanted to show Trump that this is Chicago, and we run Chicago, and we’re not going to take this,” said Green. “We got better organizers here.”

I'll ask again, where are those on the left denouncing this? Silence. Nothing. Not surprising.

This 'leader' is such a full time agitator that the security people recognized him, and he had to go incognito to even get in the event.

http://www.msnbc.com/msnbc/how-bernie-sanders-supporters-shut-down-donald-trump-rally-chicago#
 
  • Like
Reactions: mike41703
Well I have a former student at UIC that went with hundreds of students. Pretty sure they aren't professional agitators and you won't see them at any other venues. Plain old college students. And she was political as a second grader...

I'm not referring to the protests outside, which I'm sure were mostly students and locals. Protest away.

I'm talking about the full time agitators that go inside to cause mayhem.
 
More from some Bernie affiliated agitators.

“We wanted to show Trump that this is Chicago, and we run Chicago, and we’re not going to take this,” said Green. “We got better organizers here.”

I'll ask again, where are those on the left denouncing this? Silence. Nothing. Not surprising.

This 'leader' is such a full time agitator that the security people recognized him, and he had to go incognito to even get in the event.

http://www.msnbc.com/msnbc/how-bernie-sanders-supporters-shut-down-donald-trump-rally-chicago#
That's the article I shared earlier. You make it sound like these protesters are hired thugs. Moveon makes it sound like they are supporting groups they believe in. Do you understand the difference? If not, I'm done here.
 
It doesn't matter what twenty02 calls them. What matters is an honest, dispassionate description of what they are. A heckler at a comedy show is attempting to disrupt the comedy show. The rest of the audience paid good money to hear the show and the heckler is wasting their time and money. Calling the heckler a protester is a red herring. One can call a bank robber a protester too -- he's protesting that the bank has money he wants. A heckler is a heckler because he disrupts the show. A bank robber robs the bank. A disrupter disrupts. A protester protests. Each action is different and looks different, manifests itself differently.

A protester doesn't disrupt. A protester stands outside of the scene he's protesting and communicates his displeasure with that scene, whatever it is.

Calling the disrupters at Trump rallies protesters is disingenuous and a red herring. Their intent is to disrupt. IF their intent was to merely proteest while allowing the rally to continue, they'd be outside. No, their intent is to disrupt and interfere with the rally. In Chicago, the mass disruption was intended to entirely prevent the rally and they succeeded.

Be honest and call a spade a spade. Or be dishonest and call a spade something else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: twenty02
That's the article I shared earlier. You make it sound like these protesters are hired thugs. Moveon makes it sound like they are supporting groups they believe in. Do you understand the difference? If not, I'm done here.

Moveon is funding and organizing. That was my very first comment that got you all bent. I then show links of their emails and directly from their site where they confirm as much, because you refused to discuss anything about the wider issue until I gave you references.

Not really sure what your deal is here.
 
Moveon is funding and organizing. That was my very first comment that got you all bent. I then show links of their emails and directly from their site where they confirm as much.

Not really sure what your deal is here.
Goat is all bent out of shape by your choice of words. You used the word professional. Those students, whether supported by moveon or not, whether paid or not, are not professional agitators. Their profession is not to agitate. Goat will persist like a leech until you relent and recant your "professional agitator" attribution. You simply need to find an attribution that appropriately fits the intent of the Bernheads who disrupted the Chicago rally, like disrupters. Then Goat will have no rational, honest argument against.
 
Moveon is funding and organizing. That was my very first comment that got you all bent. I then show links of their emails and directly from their site where they confirm as much, because you refused to discuss anything about the wider issue until I gave you references.

Not really sure what your deal is here.
Throws up arms in disbelief.
 
Goat is all bent out of shape by your choice of words. You used the word professional. Those students, whether supported by moveon or not, whether paid or not, are not professional agitators. Their profession is not to agitate. Goat will persist like a leech until you relent and recant your "professional agitator" attribution. You simply need to find an attribution that appropriately fits the intent of the Bernheads who disrupted the Chicago rally, like disrupters. Then Goat will have no rational, honest argument against.
If people criticizing these protesters did so rationally and honestly without repeating candidate talking points that sound like conspiracy theories, Goat wouldn't need a rational argument against them, because Goat would have no desire to be in the conversation.
 
If people criticizing these protesters did so rationally and honestly without repeating candidate talking points that sound like conspiracy theories, Goat wouldn't need a rational argument against them, because Goat would have no desire to be in the conversation.
If someone is actually concerned about the so-called violence at these rallies, the key questions is, if Bernie asked his supporters to stop disrupting Trump's rallies, would they?

The common denominator to all of this is people disrupting Trump's rallies. Fact. Spin it however anyone wants, that fact remains.
 
  • Like
Reactions: twenty02
If someone is actually concerned about the so-called violence at these rallies, the key questions is, if Bernie asked his supporters to stop disrupting Trump's rallies, would they?

The common denominator to all of this is people disrupting Trump's rallies. Fact. Spin it however anyone wants, that fact remains.
There is more than one common denominator.
 
There is more than one common denominator.
On one hand we have protesters disrupting Trump's rallies, just as BLM protesters disrupted rallies for Democratic candidates. This is rude, but commonplace, and those now excoriating the Trump protesters had little trouble holding their tongues before. On the other hand we have Trump repeatedly inciting his followers to to violence against the protesters. For emphasis: the likely Republican presidential candidate has repeatedly called for lawless violence at his rallies. This is unprecedented. It requires an exceptional shallowness of thought to equate these two things.

Having said so, I agree with Charles Pierce's advice to the protesters:

Stop being played for such suckers. Stop enlisting yourself in [Trump's] bloody vaudeville. Stop giving him stuff to lie about at all the rallies that actually do end up happening. Stop making yourselves part of the show, because it's not working. It doesn't affect him at all. In fact, his campaign gains strength from it, like some science-fiction monster that absorbs the energy of whatever attacks it and then uses it to destroy. It doesn't gain you any allies; as should be clear by most of the meeping responses from the elite political press, the best it can get you is lectures about how Both Sides in our politics should settle down and let cooler heads ponder impotently about How We Got To This Point. That discussion never quite comes around to the simple, obvious fact that the Republican Party ate the monkeybrains 30 years ago and that the prion disease it thereby acquired is now cascading through its higher functions.

. . . [W]hat happened in Chicago over the weekend was tactically stupid. Yes, the rally was "shut down." Hurrah. Yes, it prompted an orgy of thumb-sucking and chin-stroking in which some people, like kindly Doc Maddow, actually pointed out the obvious truth that a madman now has more delegates to the Republican National Convention than does anyone else. And, yes, it scared the piss out of the big bag of feathers that is Marco Rubio, but he stopped quaking long enough to blame the president for "dividing Americans," which is plainly idiotic. And let's all stipulate that chanting for Bernie Sanders while you're shutting down a Trump rally is just about as stupid a political move as there is.

. . . My suggestion? Create a wave of non-violent protest outside the arenas. Close the streets. Fill the jails, if you must. Force the media coverage, which shouldn't be all that hard at this point. But stay out of the buildings because you can do no good in there. It gives aid and comfort to the forces you are trying to defeat, and it gives a timorous elite political press an excuse to look the other way, and it gives the other candidates from a party that long ago descended into madness one more hallucination to justify why it's eating bugs in public.​
 
http://m.washingtontimes.com/news/2016/mar/13/moveonorg-raising-funds-from-trump-protests-warns-/

Here is now the 3rd link I have provided.

"to the support we provided students in Chicago last night by printing signs and a banner and recruiting MoveOn.org members to join their peaceful protest. We need to double-down in the face of direct attacks on our community,” the email read.

And it pledged to continue its work.


Trump’s racist, bigoted, misogynistic, xenophobic, and violent behavior — and show the world that America rejects Trump’s hate,” the email read. “And to keep it going, we’re counting on you to donate whatever you can to cover the costs of everything involved — the organizers, signs, online recruitment ads, training, and more.”



Is that enough?
You guys are talking past each other. I think Goat is keying on the word "professionals" and you're taking liberties with that word. Is MoveOn professional? Yes. Are students (as you've pointed out in your last link) professional protestors? I doubt it.
 
ADVERTISEMENT