Okay... Tale #1... repost from before, so don't bitch (long)
Bloomington, Indiana 1991.
As I think I have related in another one of my stories, I had been living a happy life in Madison, Wisconsin right up until about two years before the events of this story. It was then that I wound up paying the wages of thinking with my johnson and the major-hottie psycho girlfriend blew up in my face, forcing me to load my possessions in my car and split town under an undeserved dark cloud of suspicion (that’s a sordid tale I’ll never tell).
I had returned to the bosom of my de-facto hometown, Bloomington, where my folks and my best mate lived. In so doing I had unwittingly tossed myself headlong over the side of the deep, dark, empty swimming pool of crappy dating.
Bloomington is a great town if you’re under 24 or 25 and in some way connected to the University… I was 27 and very much NOT connected to the University. I think I gave thumbnails of some of my more noteworthy dating horrors before, so I will spare you a re-telling… But I will go a little deeper into the precursor of one of the more uncomfortable sexual experiences I’ve had (the point of my story).
I used to spend a crapload of time in the Video Saloon. That was my hangout. I’d basically go and shoot pool for beers and hang out with my mates. I was a markedly better pool player than the average drunk bojab that wandered into that place, so I could go all night on a couple of bucks and be giving the free beers I’d won away at the end of the evening when I couldn’t drink anymore. One night I was up there and this slick moron rolls in with this really attractive little blonde woman stuck to his arm in an uncomfortable (to judge by her expression) way. The slick was eminently forgettable, but the woman was hot and she kinda stuck in my (and most of the other slack-jawed losers like myself) mind afterwards. And damned if she didn’t show up a week or so later minus the slick loser.
To make an already overly long segment of this tale shorter, Kari (the blonde’s name) decided she liked me… this should have been an indication that the Gods-of-the-relationships-between-women-and-men, who were not by biggest fans to begin with, still had me on their sh&t-list and were out mess with me yet again, but I think I’ve said I’m not good with hints, and I’m never good with ominous signs, particularly if I’m being distracted by a girl.
Partly she liked me because she was a very strong pool player herself, and she could always get a decent game from me… partly she liked me because I’m all cute and cuddly and everything… and partly she liked me because, unlike all the other guys that shot pool up there I didn’t say things like “Hey hon… I wanna cover you in whip cream and lick it off real slow” (a true offer I heard some a-hole give her) in the first 6 minutes of conversation, or suggest a different sort of wager instead of beers. Anyway, this girl was great… she was hot and she shot a mean game of pool, and she hung out in the Vid, and she liked me, and she was smart and interesting… She’d flirt with me all night and sit on my lap and look into my eyes and never leave my side… And her favorite topic of conversation was her upcoming marriage to some guy in Canada.
Seriously… She had the ring and everything… See what I mean about the Gods-of-the-relationships-between-women-and-men? They hated me for some reason.
She was engaged and the date was coming up in the fall and she spent considerable energy trying to get me to “be her boyfriend”… My mind was not healthy back then…
Anyway, one afternoon, Kari and I are up in the Vid playing pool and there isn’t anyone else in the place because it’s early (Vid heats up at 6:00 with after-work drinkers and at 11:00 with the night shift) when in rolls my best mate Tim and his littlest sister, Kelly. Tim and I grew up together in Bloomington and we’ve been like brothers since we’ve been 14. When I first met Kelly she was 10. I overhear Kelly asking Tim if Kari is my girlfriend… a question that makes Tim laugh heartily at my f-ed up predicament and say something like “Well sort of… he’s having a little trouble with that one right now.” Tim then goes on to fill his baby sister (she’s 23) in on the story of me and Kari out of Kari’s earshot and mine.
About a week or so later, I’m at home minding my own business and the phone rings… its Kelly… she wants to go to the Peanut Barrel to hear Bill Wilson (I think that was who was playing there) and she wonders if I’d like to come along, if I’m not doing anything that night. “Sure” says I. I don’t have anything going on, and Kelly’s pretty cool… I can go drink with her, no problem.
Let me back up a bit… When Tim and I were at IU together, and Kelly was 16 and 17, our buddy Bruce (same guy that burned the shack down being stupid in that long tale of camping in the desert) was obsessed with her. He really, really, really had the hots for Kelly. He about died of terminal wood once when he spent the night at Tim’s house and Kelly got up in the morning and was wandering around the house in a shortie and her underwear. Tim didn’t say anything to Bruce about it, but you could tell he was just the smallest bit uncomfortable with one of his mates lusting after his baby sister. Our friend Eric and I made heaps of fun of Bruce for his obsessions with a high school girl… You see, Kelly was like my own little sister in a “I grew up with you” way, and I completely failed to notice that she was insanely hot, even at 17… Never even began to think of her like that… at all. Foreign concept. At 23, Kelly was SMOKING hot, and I was completely oblivious to it… I’m not joking. I have female cousins I think are hot, but never once thought of Kelly like that.
So Thursday night rolls around (I believe it was Thursday) and I meet Kelly at the Peanut Barrel. She’s got this lion’s mane of ash-blonde hair and she’s wearing this skin-tight black top unzipped to the middle of her chest… and she has the equipment to be able to put that top to good uses… and perfect fitting blue jeans and black boots… Perfect makeup. She was screamingly, breathtakingly hot (I hold to this day that she was the hottest girl I ever… you know…). Clearly she’s in full battle gear and ready to make a kill. Guys were openly gaping at her in the bar. I didn’t notice …at…all. Best mate’s little sister… she’s still 10 years old in my mind… I’m totally blind to it.
We get a couple of beers and start talking… this, that, and the other thing… small talk… nice evening… Kelly’s really nice and fun to hang out with… We have lots in common and some common stories and stuff… Very enjoyable time.
To hear her tell it, she’s working it veryveryvery hard… She’s tired of dating these loser guys she’s seeing, and Tim is her favorite brother… the one she wants to be like (big Irish Catholic family, 7 kids, Kelly is youngest), she’s always been interested in what Tim likes and she always likes his mates and such… and she used to have a secret crush on me (I find out all this a few days later, by the way) and when I came back to town and she came back from Ball State, where she’s at school, she decided she really wanted to have a go with me. She’s giving me the “Come and get me” looks… no effect on me… She’s got her hand on my thigh… no effect… She’s dropping hints like atom bombs… no effect, I suck at hints and I’m just not in the same dimension mentally with her. I’m out having beers with my de facto little sister… I’m worrying about keeping guys off her. Finally (and this is another one of those mental snapshot memories I will take to my grave with me), she gives me a look like “You dumbass!” and says “Oh to hell with it!” and leans over the table and kisses me full on the mouth. Not a nice friendly “you’re just like my brother it’s nice of you to hang out with me tonight” kiss… This was a kiss not unlike Mt. Etna laid on Pompeii.
Couple of things happened at once… First my mind became not unlike that old game show “Lets make a deal!”…
“Well, Jim here is our big winner!… Lets see what’s hiding behind curtain #1!”
I instantly became aware of WHAT was sitting across the table from me and had just planted a ferocious “I want you!” kiss on me. Having your reality scrambled like that is pretty discombobulating. My best friend’s nice little 10-year old sister has been replaced by a very scary, uber-hot woman.
The second thing that happened was the classic little devil and little angel popping up on either of my shoulders…
Devil: “Okay, you moron… lets review… You’ve been sitting here with the hottest thing you’ve been this close to in 3 years, and she’s been practically begging you for anything… and you haven’t noticed. Now she just planted a mind-bomb on you…. THE GATES ARE BREACHED! GO FORTH AND PLUNDER!”
Angel: “But she’s like your own sister! Remember her when she was 10 and she was playing with dolls? What would Tim say?”
Devil: “We’re all adults here!… Lets do some adult things!… She’s BEGGING for it!… Tim won’t care! HIT IT!!!!!”
Angel: “You’ll hate yourself if you do it!”
I think I was speechless for several seconds… I then managed some Porky Pig sounds, I think… “Yibityibityibity…uuuhhhh…” Finally I think I came out with something brilliant like "Uhhh… so, you wanna get out of here?” Rarely has a moment completely stripped my brain of thoughts like that… I doubt I could have told you much passed my name in that moment.
By the way… The Devil won that little debate pretty handily, not that I probably needed to say that.
So we go out and get into her car (a beater Audi Quattro) and get better aquatinted for a few minutes… then a new problem presents itself… Where do we go? Can’t go to HER house… she’s staying at HOME for the summer… Her mom, who’s known me for 13 years is there and so, probably, is Tim… or he will be in and out of the house… So that’s CLEARLY not going to work… Can’t go to my place because my roomy is there with his buttcheeks screwed to the sofa watching stupid stuff on TV because he’s sick with the flu….. Damndamndamndamn! This is NOT funny! This is making both of us quite cranky, in fact, because we are both highly motivated… very highly motivated… Finally she says “Look… it’s late… You go home, but my mom goes off to work at 5:15 (nurse) and Tim will be gone by then (work)… so get a few hour’s sleep and show up tomorrow morning.”
I have never been good at getting up early in the morning… but hoo boy was I up and in the shower and out the door at 5:00… Get to Tim’s house at 5:15 and no Tim… Mom… yes Kelly!…
But here is where insanity begins to set in… Spend all morning doing it with my best friend’s little sister… in his house… A house I practically grew up in… After the afterglow wears off, things do not feel quite right…
I’ve been BAAAAADDDDDD…
Crap! She’s hot… she wants me… she’s all happy and cuddly… I feel like I’m on the run from the cops. And I also know I gotta tell Tim about this… he can’t just kinda stumble upon it… That’s a fun conversation!
Jim: “Hey…uhhh… So… ummm… What’s up?”
Tim: “Not much… Say, did you and Kelly go to the Peanut Barrel last night?”
Jim: “Uhhhh… yeah…yeah we did… Umm… I gotta talk to you about that one… see… uhhh…”
Tim: “What?”
Jim: “Ummm well… ummm… see… we kinda… uhhh… you know… umm… Can I date your sister?”
Cripes! My mental state is deteriorating quickly. You know how it is with a new physical relationship… you want to do it ALL the time… Each time I start feeling like I’m a criminal… I’m getting a twitch in my eye… A big part of me is finally getting over my mighty-little-man-brain and is starting to realize this is not a very comfortable relationship for me to be in… If it keeps up I’m gonna start hearing voices. But she’s SOOOOO hot!… Jeebus Cripes! Best body I’ve ever had the good fortune to be with… really good in the sack… But I’M GOING TO HEEELLLLLLLLLLL!!!!! But she’s walking around in this expensive French lingerie with that BODY, and she knows how to DO stuff!…. But I’m going to HELLLLLLLLLLLL!!!!!!
In another 2 weeks I’d have been reduced to a feeble minded mental patient, and they’d have shipped me off to some state hospital doped up on chemical straightjackets…
But I was saved…
I was working one day, not thinking about much, in a record store on Kirkwood, and this woman walks up to me and asks me sort of out of the blue if I want to have a beer with her at Nick’s… And 11 years and six months and 2 kids later, I’m doing marginally better than I was before…
Do not date your best friend’s little sister…