Really? We give away an out in that situation.....even if he was successful, we would have a guy on 3rd with one out. That's the best case scenario. When have we been able to get the runner in from 3rd with 1 out? I'm sure we have at some point, but it's a very small percentage. The inning before that proves my point....we get the first 2 guys on base and actually successfully bunt them over. And we can't get them in against pitchers with 5.58, 9.53 and 7.50 ERA's. Pathetic. How many times before he learns, that we just can't do it? Let him swing away....much better chance of him hitting him in with a base hit. Or even if he doesn't score on a hit, we have him at 3rd with no outs. And if he doesn't get it done (knocking him in), we have 3 chances for a base hit instead of 2. Sorry, I thought it was moronic - still do.
I understand your point of view, and would probably agree with it if Fineman regularly hits to the right side to move him over if he doesn't get his hit....but Fineman doesn't go to right field much. It will probably be a grounder to short or fly ball to left or a K if no hit. and a walk doesn't help much, because DP possibilities are very good with RF on 1st and Sowers hitting.
Also, Fineman is a good bunter. I wouldn't have done it with Sowers or Miller.
Now if the bunt works, all Sowers has to do his hit a grounder (if they play back) or a medium fly ball to tie the score. And if they play in, his chance of a base hit improves.
The other part of the equation was UK had been ahead the whole night, but we had some momentum and the last bat of the game. If we can tie it that late in the game, the %s are with us.