ADVERTISEMENT

Excessive Deaths

NPT

Moderator
Moderator
Aug 28, 2001
15,831
5,904
113
If you look at the following graph you can see that for the last couple months the number of deaths in the US has been less than normal. Has anyone see an explanation as to why that is? That graph is at the bottom of this page at the CDC.

Screenshot-2021-05-02-125121.jpg
 
Large number of the old and infirm have been killed off already?
 
If I had to make an out of my ass guess, I'd say it's covid vaccines slowing down the virus while we are still somewhat using covid precautions (masking, distance, not driving to social places).

One of the rants I hear from my far right friends is 'have you noticed that the flu has basically disappeared??!!' in some sort of covid is just a bad flu argument.

The answer is yeah, because when you put up a defense against Godzilla, a benefit is that it works against snake attacks also.

Anyway that would be my guess, or some kind of rebalancing as previously mentioned (as those that might have normally died have already died last year).
 
  • Like
Reactions: IU_Hickory
If you look at the following graph you can see that for the last couple months the number of deaths in the US has been less than normal. Has anyone see an explanation as to why that is? That graph is at the bottom of this page at the CDC.

Screenshot-2021-05-02-125121.jpg
That's not actually what the graph shows. The yellow line is not "normal." It is the upper bound of the 95% confidence interval.

However, Mark's answer might still be valid as a cause for deaths dropping back below that threshold.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JamieDimonsBalls
If you look at the following graph you can see that for the last couple months the number of deaths in the US has been less than normal. Has anyone see an explanation as to why that is? That graph is at the bottom of this page at the CDC.

Screenshot-2021-05-02-125121.jpg

NPT, aside from Goat's point above, you have to remember the lag effect of this data. Anything within the last month is only going to be revised further upwards. That doesn't mean we haven't seen the beginning of a reversion towards the mean, but keep that in mind.

Another aspect that is nearly impossible to quantify is the delay in elective and even critical procedures due to lockdowns, patient hesitancy, etc.

Even worse, it will be impossible to quantify the long-term impact on global health because of the restrictions of physical activity and increase in long-term mental illness. We haven't been to the gym in well over a year and while I've attempted to do some moderate exercises at home, get outside and do more outdoor activity, etc. my cardio and physical health is far worse in Spring 2021 after a year of COVID than Spring 2020.
 
Another aspect that is nearly impossible to quantify is the delay in elective and even critical procedures due to lockdowns, patient hesitancy, etc.
You would think that would cause more deaths wouldn't you? People not going to the doctor or getting a procedure done when they should has been mentioned as part of the excessive deaths.
I am interested in whether the numbers will be revised upwards.
 
You would think that would cause more deaths wouldn't you? People not going to the doctor or getting a procedure done when they should has been mentioned as part of the excessive deaths.
I am interested in whether the numbers will be revised upwards.

Of course that is some percentage of the excess. Quantifying it is the problem. But, my larger point was, our excess deaths trendline may rise for a while and I certainly expect life expectancy to fall for the foreseeable future.
 
One of my best friends is a pathologist who for many years has complained about coroners and death reports.

Please qualify this by pointing out his experience is limited to Marion County,Indiana.

Nevertheless, i cannot believe that death reporting problems exist outside of Marion County.

At the risk of being called a big government liberal, can I suggest having national standards which are adhered to might help in regard to the death statistics regarding the impact of Covid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NPT
NPT, aside from Goat's point above, you have to remember the lag effect of this data. Anything within the last month is only going to be revised further upwards. That doesn't mean we haven't seen the beginning of a reversion towards the mean, but keep that in mind.

Another aspect that is nearly impossible to quantify is the delay in elective and even critical procedures due to lockdowns, patient hesitancy, etc.

Even worse, it will be impossible to quantify the long-term impact on global health because of the restrictions of physical activity and increase in long-term mental illness. We haven't been to the gym in well over a year and while I've attempted to do some moderate exercises at home, get outside and do more outdoor activity, etc. my cardio and physical health is far worse in Spring 2021 after a year of COVID than Spring 2020.
Yep. Takes a month or two for numbers to catch up to reality.
 
One of my best friends is a pathologist who for many years has complained about coroners and death reports.

Please qualify this by pointing out his experience is limited to Marion County,Indiana.

Nevertheless, i cannot believe that death reporting problems exist outside of Marion County.

At the risk of being called a big government liberal, can I suggest having national standards which are adhered to might help in regard to the death statistics regarding the impact of Covid.
That being said, whatever problems exist are baked into both the trend line and the 95% prediction range, so significant deviations from either - especially when they can be linked with specific real-world events expected to affect mortality - are unlikely to be statistical artifacts or false positives. In other words, it's extremely unlikely that we just happen to see spikes associated with a bad 2018 flu season and the Covid pandemic and that those spikes don't exist in reality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hoot1
That being said, whatever problems exist are baked into both the trend line and the 95% prediction range, so significant deviations from either - especially when they can be linked with specific real-world events expected to affect mortality - are unlikely to be statistical artifacts or false positives. In other words, it's extremely unlikely that we just happen to see spikes associated with a bad 2018 flu season and the Covid pandemic and that those spikes don't exist in reality.
That's true...when I've seen where someone has called Covid a hoax I've pointed them to the graph and pointed out that it shows the bad 2018 flu season and then point out all the excessive deaths since Covid hit.
 
All the fake deaths add up. Truly diabolical. Fauci is like Dr Evil.
There are deaths that attributed to Covid that aren't caused by Covid but the graph tells the story. My sister (87) died last year and it had Covid as a reason on the death certificate but it wasn't a cause at all. She had it probably 7-8 before but didn't have any symptoms but then fell and broke her hip and that started the downward spiral to her death
 
  • Sad
Reactions: hookyIU1990
ADVERTISEMENT