The way I read this you’d get rid of Hartman, but keep Priller?! Assume you mean get rid of Priller too. I think it’s obvious Archie played the long game on this, and chose to start establishing real, solid, good relationships with Indiana high school and AAU people. Canning Hartman, coming off an injury might have damaged that effort. Though I seem to remember Hartman actually needed convincing to play...as he was already graduated and engaged. Guessing Archie felt like he wanted Colins leadership to get his program going.
And the type of kids Archie was likely to get for the Prillers and Hartmans, anyone he would have bumped that year, likely would have been more of a reach than a Forrester type kid. Though Jake has actually done well at his next stop. No coach hits on all their recruits. And we know Archie isn’t like Crean with his Schollies. He’ll bank them before reaching on someone. Hindsight is always 20/20.
If he had blown it up, and won 5 or so games less his first couple seasons as a result, you’d be using that as a reason to question him now.
Ad I’ve mentioned before, you’re not nuanced. You aren’t seeing the improvements and what he’s building. You either don’t know, or don’t understand the principles, personnel, and complete buy in it takes to build a successful pack line program. It doesn’t happen overnight. Never has for any pack line coach. When they get there, if they’ve done a good job establishing a reliable roster, they’ll stay there...a la Wisconsin and Virginia.
I think we’re now either there, or knocking on the door of being there. And 10 years from now we’ll look back and be very happy with this next decade of IU basketball.